GoneWithTheSubway, a photo from Istanbul, Marmara

Photographer's Note

None

Critiques | Translate

MiguelP (14470) 2005-10-21 11:26

Good photo. The effect of the train creates such a strange and endless effect that I like a lot. The tilt works fine, you were lucky she did not move an inch. Congratulations.

sarju (5324) 2005-10-21 11:27

Hi Selcuk
what a nice photo ... strong statement with a girl standing still and the train moving in a two sec shot ..... I guess you were very lucky that the person did not move even in two secs
tfs ... sarjju

mrbialy (2568) 2005-10-21 11:28

Hello. Very original and interesting. Colours like from artpainter- beautiful. I like here: point of view, cought moment, captured, compo. Very good, original stuff. good luck

Philippe (11836) 2005-10-21 11:28

Hello, Selcuk. I like your composition here with all these lines and the contrast between the moving lines of the train and the lines on the platform. This conveys an idea of speed in a static image. Well done.

[2]

jurgen (2074) 2005-10-21 11:30

What a picture. Half of it is running very fast and the other is waiting still. As sarju said, you were lucky because the girl did not move. The 2 sec exposure created the perfect effect of movement with the right amount of blur.

lewiz (1297) 2005-10-21 11:33

Brilliant perspective and tilt!
Simple clear lines with repetition and a lone subject make for a truly great shot.
In fact, I can't quite get over how brilliant the repetition is!

midyat (2545) 2005-10-21 11:35

Selçuk bey harika bir çalisma. Tebrik ederim. çok begendim...

HNIK (1104) 2005-10-21 11:36

What a nice and interesting shot,Selcuk!
The colorful lines are so nice in this shot.
and ths shot has a special view.
very nice with well composition.
very well done
Best Wishes

YavuzA (357) 2005-10-21 11:40

Selam!
Süper bir calisma olmus! Fikir, aci, zamanlama, kisacasi hersey mükemmel!
Tebrikler

Yavuz

gringofil (0) 2005-10-21 12:03

This is great. I really like how you managed to find such simplicity in the most crowded of places...a train or subway station. The colors are great and the movement shown very well. Good work!

gelor (3233) 2005-10-21 12:10

Une belle composition qui donne un ensemble très intéressant. meric pour le partage. Gérard

AmiBe (6042) 2005-10-21 12:16

Hi Selcuk,
one of the best picture I've seen today.
The aerial POV works well, I like the lines in front of and behind the woman.
The slow speed effect is excellent and add more lines.
An excellent graphical shot.
Well done

naxius (16685) 2005-10-21 12:57

Splendid urban shot Selcuk..
I like the diagonal you have catched and the colors..
Very very good.
Bravo!
Alex

sengir (4956) 2005-10-21 13:01

splendid composition, one of such cases that tilt was absolutely justified. Could work as the example of "how good composition makes a good picture"

wishnugaruda (1305) 2005-10-21 15:03

Hi Selcuk,
wow, this is marvelous, a little abstract and with nice colours. A wonderful idea, perfect
thanks and bye
Sabine - wishnugaruda

Ina (2687) 2005-10-21 15:21

Exelent shot.... The golden lines and the girl waiting makes a fantastic composition...TFS...Ina...

anesugur (18789) 2005-10-21 15:30

Fazla söze gerek yok, HARİKA bir fotoğraf.
Tebrikler. Uğur

ahmetgedikli (25609) 2005-10-21 16:05

Bu görüntüye ekleyecek bir şey yok.Mükemmel...
Eline sağlık. Ahmet

ALSOM (6616) 2005-10-21 18:22

I have to admit this the shot I prefer the most today. Very artistic capture wit the colorful and straight red/blue/yellow lignes.
I noted the same color coding between her pants and coats and the lignes.

Better not to cross the yellow lignes, you did it with this compo.
Thanks,
Al.

vapours (8264) 2005-10-21 21:26

Brilliant series of lines here, very crisp and clear as well.

serdarhepgul (1744) 2005-10-22 5:10

Çook Çokk güzel bir resim..resimdeki hareket, buna karşın kadının durgunluğu hoş bir karşıtlık oluşturuyor.Renkler çook güzel.Çizgilerin paralelliği ise gözü okşuyor.Muhteşem olmuş ellerinize sağlık
Serdar

recepyuksel (18640) 2005-10-22 10:06

öncelikle bu muhteşem....
hem renk şov, hem de grafik şov... inanılmaz.
Sarı-kırmızı ve mavi hat olağnüstü güzellikte. Model tam kompozisyona uygun. A+++
İçten tebriklerimi kabul edin...
Selamlar.

selman (371) 2005-10-22 10:14 [Comment]

Show Comment

ahmet54 (3490) 2005-10-22 12:14

Merhaba Selcuk,
it looks like a pop-art painting. The parallel lines are colourful and sharp. The train seems to be already moving. The woman is left over behind the yellow line.
Tebrikler,
Roland alias ahmet54

greg (2835) 2005-10-24 3:45

so elegant...

moxon (78) 2005-10-25 3:13

Minamalist but striking. Great composition and use of colour. Well done.

Or_Han (815) 2005-11-07 4:17

ÇOK GÜZEL, AKILLICA. :)

maciekda (19895) 2005-11-08 6:21

this one is really nice, I remember it from some time ago... very good composition - all those colorful lines and that standing woman, colors are so nice here, they match very well. nice and aesthetic work

alekpet (4663) 2005-11-08 7:45

Very nice and aestetic.
The tilt and hi perspective work together very well.
The woman cooperated well by not moving.

Aleks

ybaki (349) 2005-11-08 8:10

Bu fotograf hakkaten muthis olmus. Cok begendimi ve etkilendigimi belirtmeliyim. Cesitli renk, kalinlik ve boydaki cizgiler cok guzel gorunuyor. Icten ve samimi tebrikler... :)

mayabee (374) 2005-11-10 11:46

Hi Selcuk,
I LOVE this photo, the composition is brilliant, and the red coat of the woman is exactly what you needed in this photo.
Cheers,
Maya

jsec (2154) 2005-11-10 19:16

This is quite perfect. I am extremely impressed. Great point of view, subject and exposure. Congratulations. One of my favourites.

Regards

Jeff

Abadpour (49) 2005-11-10 19:45 [Comment]

Show Comment

canbalci (219) 2005-11-11 1:50

Great diagonal composition. Muhtesem renkler. Tebrikler!

hyasar (7775) 2005-11-12 6:29

Merhaba Selcuk,

muhtesem bir poz. POV, shutter speed o kadar iyi kullanilmis ki.

tebrikler ve tesekkurler,
Hakan

beyaz_toprak (355) 2005-11-16 3:33

Selçuk bey, arayı açan sizsiniz.. Güzel bir kare metro treninin cizdiği muhteşem renkleri fotoğrafa yansıtmak güzel bir fotoğrafı birlikte getirmiş..

Selamlar
Hayrettin YENEL
Niğde Gazeteciler Cemiyeti Başkanı

Amphitrite (1720) 2005-11-26 10:11

Selam Selcuk!
Super bir fotograf...
Yine renklerin ahengi muthis ve hareket etkisi cok güzel. Eline saglik,
Pinar

izmirli (3989) 2005-11-28 14:46

Bravo Selçuk, harika olmuş....

uzaklar (684) 2006-01-24 12:13

Selamlar,
Bu Fotografa ne denilebilirki ? MUTHIS !!!!

ozaydin (620) 2006-01-25 6:10

Merhaba Selcuk,
Yaratici bir calisma :) Cok begendim...
Ellerine saglik.
Ozaydin

david (3992) 2006-01-25 6:13

wow! just wow!

i've tried similar shots to try and get motion blur on a subway, but none as well as this! beautifully done!

tjanze (5674) 2006-01-28 11:07

Hi Selcuk!
Wow! Great composition.I think this is train passing and make this lines.Fantastic shot.
Bravo!

bigtim (3518) 2006-01-29 14:48 [Comment]

Show Comment

elBud (2237) 2006-02-20 14:41

Selcuk, esta es una super fotografia, muy buen efecto en el tren, los colores estan super buenos, muy buena composicion.

sencer (240) 2006-03-01 17:39

Merhaba,
Dolaşırken fotoğraflarda, buna rastlamak.. Çok çok güzel. Mühendis gözüyle çekildiği de hissediliyor fotoğrafta :) Tebrikler...

SMD

Mistral (15402) 2006-03-03 12:37

Selamlar Selcuk,
great graphism with colours.
Excellent original framing.
A smile
Luca

olirey (193) 2006-04-06 9:39

Impressive. It's like if one half of your picture is indefinitely moving, and by contrast, the other half is completely still.
I like it a lot.

craiggc (2509) 2006-04-06 10:06

Nice shot Selcuk - you were lucky to be abot to get such a high viewpoint.

The details and sharpness are good as well.

Sina (1118) 2006-08-07 7:32

SelçukBey,
Portfolyonuzu yeni farkettim. Güzel fotoğraflarla dolu. Bu fotoğraf içlerinden en hoşuma gideni oldu. Tebrikler

talatbay (2428) 2006-09-14 23:10

Merhaba Selçuk bey,
mükemmel bir bakış açısı yakalamışsınız. Digonal yerleşimle, renk armonisi ile son derecede estetik bir görüntüyü bizlere sunduğunuz için kutluyorum.

marknunnerley (2780) 2006-10-31 6:31

Hi Selcuk,
marked your seagull yesterday but came across this later. What a fantastic graphical and colourful shot. Really good pov and composition here resulting in a striking image.
Mark

Burberry1 (6041) 2006-10-31 6:33

Excellent capture with an original angle and really POWERFUL one!
Theres no way not to notice this image!!

Agnieszka

indiana_gs (174) 2006-12-13 12:55 [Comment]

Show Comment

kaptan (1444) 2006-12-19 7:27

selcuk bu fotogafına bayıldım.harika.hepsi güzel ama bu başka güzel.nezih

Pandrews (96) 2007-01-11 16:49

Hi Selcuk

The geometric lines and the colours make this a very striking image. The lone figure just completes what is a great photo. I'm not usually a fan of borders but here it is understated and adds to the effect.
Well done!

Paul

KKar (486) 2007-08-17 1:30

Another wonderful one Selcuk
The idea is again original and the otcome artistic in an impressionistic way
Regards
Kostas

sotiris_k (838) 2007-08-17 8:27

Hi Selcuk!
Your picture captivated my eyes as soon as I saw it! Great POV.

TFS

Sotiris

sebinho342 (19329) 2007-10-02 11:27

This is a terrific shot Selcuk, i would be so proud to have made that one ;)
A pearl here on TE, exactly what i looove in photography
All my congratulations

Epop (79) 2007-10-02 14:03

Terrific shot SELCUK! with new see sight! Congratulations... I've got a shot like yours too!! make me happy if you check it out: http://www.trekearth.com/gallery/Middle_East/photo746196.htm
"sebinho342" awared me about your shot and how similar subject we used!

Regards,
Ehsan...

livermore (1631) 2012-10-14 1:53

Bonjour Selcuk,
Excellente photo, graphisme, couleur, cadrage, tout est parfaitement maitrisé.
Amitiés
Vincent