Photographer's Note
In the far N. E. of Thailand, near Chiang Saen, a short drive will bring you to an area where Hill Tribe people live. Tribes such as Karen, Lisu, Hmong and Akha have been crossing in to Thailand for generations although more recently, Karen have been driven into border areas by The Burmese Army. Throughout the north of Thailand, the influence of the West is prevalent. It is strange to see a little wooden hut....with a satelite dish attached. I reserve my my opinion as to the work of Christian missionaries and here is why. This particular HIll Tribe village was an Akha village and as I entered It was pointed out that I must pass through the village's Spirit Gate. This was a doorway like arrangement made from sticks and nearby, a large wooden carving of a copulating couple proved an interesting sight. My guide was very definite, that I was not to touch anything from 'outside' the gate and bring it in. The gate serves the purpose of symbolic separation of the outside world and the inside world. I was the only visitor to this village and as I got closer, I could hear some drumming. I didn't think much about it but as I passed through the gate I could feel a cold prickle running up my back..it felt decidedly strange. OK..so what about the other Christian tribal villages? There are many where missionaries have gone in ...and I have seen them...but I could never find their 'Spirit Gate' at these villages. Its a shame that the missionaries can't go into these places..do their good work ..but leave the tribal belief systems intact.
This old man is an Akha tribal elder, he had probably seen many like me before..he just sat there with the wisdom of ages in his face and smiled enigmaticly at me.
Cropped, converted with B & W Pro
BrittanyS, marknunnerley, CliffW has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
BrittanyS
(229) 2007-06-27 18:30
Beautiful work and detail. Wonderful BW conversion - I can imagine I would much prefer it as a BW as opposed to colour. Chiang Saen is truly an amazing place.
dvlazar
(6662) 2007-06-27 19:40
What a wonderful portrait of this old man. The black and white is perfect, and the detail and clarity also great,
Well done,
Dave.
rosiegirl
(1596) 2007-06-28 2:35
Great portrait. The depth of the tones are so rich- they compliment the richness of his wrinkled skin. The textures of his clothing and hat have shown up so well- good job.
Rosie
Furachan
(0) 2007-06-28 3:46
FIne portrait Ken, unwavering, focused, revealing. The BW treatment shows some harsh highlights, could be a matter of taste but that's the only area where I might have a nitpick.
Best wishes,
Francis
kinginexile
(2598) 2007-06-28 4:09
Well, Ken, I was born in Paris, 1955, emigrated to the US in 1980, first dicovered Thailand in 88, then...
Sorry, Man, I thought your title was a question to us...;-)
Like Francis, I think the area of highlight along his left cheek is a bit distracting, the sharpness is top, bringing mch presence and punch to the portrait, it really "introduces" us to this old man, all this helped by the good contact you established with him at that moment. I see many might find his smile your basic "hello to you, tourist, wellcome to tribe-iland", lacking a bit of the social component you point to in your note.
But I also noticed an amusing detail, funnily his bonnet reminds me of the shape of the army helmets seen on parade Days in Bangkok.
About the missionaries, yes, at the same time, take them off, and maybe these tribes wouldn't still be left alone, and less well-wishing modern-world creatures of different greed and creed might have done even more harm, unheeded by the presence of the White God's envoys. Catch 22?
marknunnerley
(2780) 2007-06-28 5:06
Fantastic and heartwarming portrait Ken. Absolutely excellent b&w conversion, truly impressive. Shame as you say that the Christians are not allowed in to do there work.
What is the B & W Pro? I will not rest until I find out ;)
br
mark
gabrielpat
(7163) 2007-06-29 15:05
a great quality for this portrait in B/W,exellent managing of the light.a nice complice lady.
CliffW
(2381) 2007-07-04 12:31
Ken, I'm traveling back and catching up a bit. Getting a chance to see some of the excellent photos I've missed. This one is a bit unusual for you, being a portrait without a lot of surrounding context. However, what you have managed to convey is a lot of warmth from your subject, even a little bit of mischief. Warmth's not an easy thing to portray in B&W. But you've got some fine detail here. If I ever were to meet up with you, I'm afraid I'd have to insist on a lesson in B&W conversion!
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Ken McColl (kenmac)
(529)
- Genre: People
- Medium: Black & White
- Date Taken: 2006-05-12
- Categories: Daily Life
- Camera: Canon 5D, 24 - 105 if4 IS L
- Exposure: f/4, 1/100 seconds
- More Photo Info: view
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Date Submitted: 2007-06-27 18:04
Discussions
- To marknunnerley: Hi (4)
by kenmac, last updated 2007-06-28 01:24 - To CliffW: re Whats your story (2)
by kenmac, last updated 2007-07-07 10:26