Photographer’s Note
Built in 1620 as the administrative centre for the Royal Burgh of Dunbar, the Town House is currently undergoing restoration. Last week the wraps were taken off the exterior, and now we can see the building looking as it did back then in the 17th century, its local Old Red Sandstone covered in 'sacrificial' lime harl. In 1913 the original coating, and many subsequent layers, were removed because people thought it more romantic and historically interesting to see the red rubble walls. They did not realise that the stone would be rapidly eroded by
winds from the sea.
In contrast to cement-based renders, lime harl breathes; it absorbs moisture and gradually lets it re-evaporate, protecting the soft stone beneath. Three coats have been applied, and for each the harl was closely covered to ensure it dried slowly over several days. The lime interacts with light in a lively manner. The apparent colour seems to depend on how the light falls on it, and on the colour of the sky behind. An hour after I took this shot there was a dark cloud in the sky and the harl had a pronounced pink tinge; it can look white in the morning sun.
The spire is pentagonal, so it appears very lopsided from some perspectives! The clocks are 19th century. The numbers on the sundial are Roman numerals. See Workshop.
Decorative details such as the corbelled string courses are typical of the distinctive Scottish Renaissance architecture of the 16th and 17th centuries (utterly different from the contemporary Jacobean style in England). Scots nobles no longer needed castles for defence, and built new dwellings designed by architects who incorporated castle-like features as status symbols. The common arrangement was a smooth harled plinth contrasting with exuberant corbels, dormer windows, crowsteps and false gun-slits at the higher levels. A good illustration of this on Trek Earth is Dougie's photo of the west facade at Crichton which was built in 1581 as an extension to the old keep. Sadly, as in hundreds of other places, the harl there was not maintained and the stone decayed. But many magnificent buildings did survive and are now tourist attractions.
Not all Dunbar's residents are happy about the result of our Town House restoration. "It looks too modern," according to a teenager who served me in one of the High Street shops.
Architectural
description.
14 Mar 2009
Alastair has now followed up his WS with an
identical view which shows the texture of the harl.
Critiques | Translate
AROBN54
(10721) 2009-02-27 17:05
Hi, Winifred,
ANOTHER pretty one! I love those marvelous lines and angles, the clean sharp detail, and that nice close-in view. What I REALLY like, though, is that incredibly blue sky. That is beautiful. Bet it looked even better to you, though, eh?? :)) Wonderfully done! Many thanks and warmest regards,
Shelly
batalay
(20788) 2009-02-28 15:53
Hello Winifred,
A superb note. I was fascinated by the teenager's comment, in effect, that it looked too modern. It is the old timer who who suppose to comment about how the old was better. Your composition with the spire dominating one side, and the street light on the other side as a counterpoint to the spire works well.
Warm regards, and have a good Sunday,
(I showed your fabulous website to a friend, a physicist, who was equally impressed as I was upon first seeing it.)
Bulent
auldal
(1023) 2009-03-01 6:03
A lovely shot of a fascinating old building. I can understand the need to reharl it to protect it. There are so many amazing sandstone walls in Dunbar, but they do deteriorate with being so close to the effects of the North Sea, wind and salt spray.
I'm uploading a photo to your workshop showing the state of the stonework before the re-restoration.
Older View of the Town House tower
I hope some of the other buildings in the High Street get the attention they need as well.
Alastair
cihandoger
(270) 2009-03-02 23:45
Hi, Winifred,
Good POV, good ligth,good contrast and good photo
Well done.
Regards
dumbo
(4336) 2009-03-04 23:43
Hello Winifred,
I like that beautiful old tower against the light blue sky.
Good details and sharpness.
Well done!
Regards,
Eino
jmdias
(18991) 2009-03-10 16:08
winifred
very beautiful building. I liked the pov you choose. The light is soft and show us each detail nicely. I would prefer a framing a little more far, leting more space around the building, but not so much. anyway it is a nice job.
thank you for WS you did for my photo.
hugs
jorge
LamCam
(3603) 2009-03-13 13:22
Hello Winifred, It seems I missed this one. The tower looks very handsome in its new coat - it should be well protected for a long time after this work has been carried out with such care. Excellent colour and clarity in this shot and a note full of interest.
Best wishes....Maggie
anesugur
(16720) 2009-03-15 11:14
Hello Winifred,
Very good POV, nice colors and sharpness.
Very well seen and done.
Best wishes. Uğur
mafegan
(4063) 2009-06-15 2:11
Hello Winifred
There are angles and lines going in many directions and they are perfectly sharp against the blue sky. Simple but effective. Tfs, Marlene
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Winifred Sillitto (windosil)
(764) - Genre: Places
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2009-02-19
- Categories: Daily Life, Architecture
- Camera: Canon IXUS50
- Exposure: f/4.5, 1/400 seconds
- More Photo Info: view
- Photo Version: Original Version, Workshop
- Date Submitted: 2009-02-27 15:26
Discussions
- To auldal: old stone (1)
by windosil, last updated 03-01 12:39 - To AROBN54: note added (1)
by windosil, last updated 02-28 14:06








