basket carriers

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• ninadev (5053)
• [2003-07-24 18:30]
• [2] - [workshop] [compare]

Well seen! Daily life in Nepal is hard work.
First photo I've seen of people in Nepal who do not seem so calm and relax. These girls were really in a hurry it seems. I did my homework again and propose a different version of this one: different cropping and tried to improve sharpness and colors.

•  
• Motrem (2392)
• [2003-07-24 20:22]
• [2]

Votre photo a attiré mon attention. J'aime beaucoup le sujet et la composition. J'ai regardé aussi les deux ws et j'ai finalement opté pour celui de Caprice parce que le cadrage vertical donne l'impression que ces dames viennent du haut de la colline et sont pressées de descendre. Bravo à tous, quel effort!

•  
• evilren (1395)
• [2003-07-24 21:47]
• [2]

nice pic but I am afraid the square framing doesn't fit for this photo..it does have some potential..but could use a small fix..the red isn't strong enough and the grass infront is a bit distracting..just seen nina's workshop >much better.

•  
• gringofil (0)
• [2003-07-25 0:42]
• [3]

Greg, you KNOW what I'm gonna say. Nina's version is amazing or maybe I'm just getting old and not embracing new ideas as I should. The word that comes to mind when I saw her WS is: dynamic.

•  
• Aegean (2559)
• [2003-07-25 3:19]

Subject and composition are great...

•  
• Porteplume (3066)
• [2003-07-25 6:00]

Great capture in the mouvement... It needed some crop indeed and I like Nina's WS because it keeps the mouvement in it.

•  
• Mike (693)
• [2003-07-25 10:10]

Do you know Greg, I'm getting to really like these grainier images from your previous camera, I mean, I liked them from the offset, but they are really growing on me now, they have a sort of mellow feel about them that digital photography just doesn't have, hope there are plenty more!

•  
• pridel (233)
• [2004-05-13 8:50]

moi j'aime beaucoup cette composition telle qu'elle est. nous sommes bien dans une montagne et ce format là convient très bien. c'est vrai aussi qu'il y a du dynamisme dans cette photo. j'aime beaucoup. le ws de ninadev est bien aussi mais différent