<< Previous Next >>

life goes on


life goes on
Photo Information
Copyright: korkut bostanci (bostankorkulugu) Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2918 W: 657 N: 6143] (26861)
Genre: People
Medium: Black & White
Date Taken: 2008-01-02
Categories: Daily Life, Architecture
Photo Version: Original Version
Theme(s): Great Mysteries of TE, Tribute to HCB, Camondo Stairs, Moody, Manamo's favs of each day of 08 (Jan,Feb,mar), Bwiti la veut !, More than 100, Sasa's Favourites, 200-300, Favorites - portraits/people 01, up and down the stairs [view contributor(s)]
Date Submitted: 2008-01-02 18:22
Viewed: 2070
Favorites: 16 [view]
Points: 246
[Note Guidelines] Photographer's Note
As life goes on,
Pain is felt,
Tears are cried
And miseries are put into the utmost bottom of your heart...
The truth has to be accepted,
The past cannot be altered,
But the future can,
Life goes on, live it.
But as people say this,
It is hard to let go,
As I know this myself,
The pains will not leave,
I tell myself,
Life goes on
Over and over again.
No effect.
Why is this?
When you know the truth,
When you know what to do,
It just doesn’t work,
As the saying goes
“Life goes on”
Live with it,
But me personally,
I cannot.

(levi chang)






...Camondo stairs in Galata, Istanbul...

COSTANTINO, nivaldo, Brian, Wanda1, carper, ARGI, azaf1, jorgi, anes_lc, Photo65Net, salvator, imrek, isabela_sor, Merline, Budapestman, Cretense, broglia, TopGeo, siolaw, ocskaymarci, stego, tehanu_f, gary91, evanrizo, KevRyan, feather, kiwi_explorer, papagolf21, syd1946, jafadabret, pboehringer, AyseGurel, testmaniac, riclopes, ALIRIZA, ifanik, Vato_Law, vincz, Paolo, AiresSantos, pasternak, elifpetan, saylan-cb, mikeo, kdialyna, steliosk, yogi32, tzourob, avene has marked this note useful
Only registered TrekEarth members may rate photo notes.
Add Critique [Critiquing Guidelines] 
Only registered TrekEarth members may write critiques.
Discussions
ThreadThread Starter Messages Updated
To nimish23: io non sono anna, ma korkut!bostankorkulugu 2 10-27 06:57
To MayaG: tnx:)bostankorkulugu 1 05-21 00:23
To brevbrev14: ciao!bostankorkulugu 1 01-30 09:07
To KevRyan: dumbo!bostankorkulugu 1 01-04 07:34
To Dionysos: buldum:)bostankorkulugu 1 01-03 11:56
To mesutilgim: HCBbostankorkulugu 1 01-03 11:29
To rigoletto: iz gez gozbostankorkulugu 1 01-03 11:19
You must be logged in to start a discussion.

Critiques [Translate]

A great and clever composition!
A nice B&W presentation!
Congratulations. TFS.
Brazilian Greetings,
Nivaldo

  • Great 
  • Brian Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 243 W: 12 N: 149] (1171)
  • [2008-01-02 19:42]

The white haired man clothed in black walking up the white stairs makes a great compo. I like how you can barely see his face as he climbs the curvy stairs. Great BW tones. Wondering what kind of camera, lens, etc. you used here though.

Take care,
Brian

  • Great 
  • Wanda1 Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1226 W: 21 N: 1561] (8777)
  • [2008-01-02 19:47]

Hi Korkut,
I love this shot, it reminds me of an Escher drawing with all the winding stairs in different directions. You have a great point of view and the man in his dark clothing contrasts well with the grey stairs. Black and white was a great chioce enhancing the mood.
Regards
Wanda

We just keep climbing the stairs. What else can we do? They wind away beneath us. The curve away above us. Our hair grows whiter with each step, our light dims with each flight. Excellent composition, Korkut. And thoughts for the new year. Not rosy, but as true as the stark black and white of this image. Best, -Hugh

  • Great 
  • BLO Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Note Writer [C: 58 W: 0 N: 27] (180)
  • [2008-01-02 21:18]

i love it... I like how the stairs draw the geometrical figures almost like in architects drawings, but that is great that you included the man in this shot. Good choice..

  • Great 
  • carper Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 9655 W: 445 N: 15929] (56348)
  • [2008-01-02 23:14]

very nice one Korkut.
I like the curl in the shot witch is very nice in black and white, good photojob and have a good 2008 for you and your family.
gr. jaap

meşhur merdivenlere farklı bakış,
amcamın omuzlarının eğikliği ve başının önde oluşu ile 4/4lük olmuş,
tebrix,
selamlar,
mutlu 2008
nilgün

Beautiful curves. Bw seems a very wise choice to me, helping to concentrate on shapes. Human brings life to this frame. Very good shot.
Best regards
Joanna

  • Great 
  • ARGI Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 759 W: 4 N: 369] (3388)
  • [2008-01-02 23:25]

Congratulations Korkut.
Amazing point of view, excellent POV.
Fantastic poem and title.
It's a very successful moment to find this man on this serpant stairs.
Best regards Argyris

merhaba korkut abi

oy oy oy, S&B harikası bir kare abi,
gerçekten şahane, bende çekmek isterdim böyle bir kare
ellerine sağlık

veysel

Hello Korkut,

The combination of the swirling stairwell, assorted textures in the concrete, and even that white swirl of hair that we see, all work well in harmony here.

Super merdivenler bunlar! Cektigin aciya ve dar kadrajina bayildim. Mesut beyin notuna da bayildim. Eline saglik.

Sevgili Korkut,
1953 ile 1961 yılları arasında, bir Avusturya Lisesi talebesi olarak en az 2500 kere inip çıkmışım bu merdivenlerden ! Karaköy'ün ünlü Kamando merdivenleri ! 1785-1873 arasında yaşamış ünlü banker Avram Kamando'nun yaptırdığı merdivenler.
Ama hiçbir zaman bu gözle görmemiştim bu merdivenleri. Belki de kafamızdaki tek şey'in bir an evvel caddeye fırlayıp, merdivenin sondan ikinci basamağından, yoldan geçmekte olan Harbiye-Fatih tramvayı'nın sahanlığına atlamak geçtiği için.
Gözüne sağlık,
İyi seneler, selam ve sevgiler
MESUT ILGIM

PS.Bana e-mail adresini boş bir mail ile yollarsan, sana kolleksyonumdan, Henry Cartier Bresson'un çektiği "Kamando merdivenlerini" gönderirim.

Very beautiful B&W picture. In this case the strong contrast and no colors add some dramaticity. I like the geometrical pattern, and the slightlu blurred head.
Ciao Stefano

  • Great 
  • azaf1 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1658 W: 132 N: 2334] (10651)
  • [2008-01-03 0:46]

Kalimera Korkut
A very dramatic metaphor of the note you have writte. B/W for emphasis, great geometrical designs and incredible stability in the framing
What els!
Congratulations
Argiris

  • Great 
  • jorgi Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 912 W: 129 N: 709] (3075)
  • [2008-01-03 0:58]

Hi Korkut,

my biggest compliment for this capure and the note. It is so strongly filled with emotions it hurts watching it. This is it! That's what photography is about. My sincere admiration.

Best regards,
Jeri

merhaba korkut bey
çok yakından tanıdığım ve defalarca merdivenlerini aşındırdığım bu bildik mekanı çok güzel bir açıdan kadraja almışsın.özellikle insan faktörü çok önemli bir rol oynuyor ayrıca siyah beyaz tercihide yerinde bir karar olmuş eline sağlık.
selamlar
Ali

  • Great 
  • faubry Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 3691 W: 358 N: 4455] (28941)
  • [2008-01-03 1:06]

HAAPY NEW YEAR dear friend..s very nice graphic shot with this stair and i like this man go up,and white hairs are superb... bravo
francine

Merhaba
cok etkileyici kompozisyon be bakis acisi
tebrikler

best wishes for the new year dear...
i saw the santa in your intro...he is so sweet :)
great shot like always ...surprising POV :D
hugs,anes

Korkut,
Superb curves and geometrics !
You played with these graphical stairs, so well done.
Another picture from you I'd have love to make :o)
Regards,
JB.

  • Great 
  • ninaL Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1827 W: 268 N: 1966] (16483)
  • [2008-01-03 1:38]

Wow, wow, wow !!!
Incredible composition.
The best photograph with strars I have never seen.
Best regards. Grazyna.

  • Great 
  • imrek Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1361 W: 65 N: 1239] (6494)
  • [2008-01-03 2:40]

Hi Korkut,

very nice b/w shot, good low POV and fine hues!

Happy New Year!

rgs,

imre

The master of the stairs :)
the perspective and the human presence make your picture a masterpiece
A happy 2008 for you and your nice family
And many kisses for Kuzey

Merhaba Korkut,
Guzel bakis acisi, guzel kontrast, siyah beyaz secimi de yerinde olmus. Kesikinlik, salyangoz gibi kivrilan merdivenler harika.
Eline saglik. Selamlar. Salvator.
PS.hehehe komikti degil mi? Bir tane daha geldi, onu da gondereyim sana.

Hi Korkut
Interesting composition you captured.I like the curves of the winding stairs and the man ascending it.Wonderful point of view.
Compliments
Karina

Hello Korkut,
what an interesting and powerful composition...I love the silvery tones, the man in black, lonely and going up these stairs, the architecture of those well presented with this point of view. Great note to go with it, a pic that makes us think and exudes emotion, very symbolic.

TFS
Best regards

  • Great 
  • newra Silver Star Critiquer [C: 18 W: 0 N: 3] (135)
  • [2008-01-03 4:09]

çok hoş ve farklı bir açıdan ele almışsınız, tebrikler.
Ayrıca siyah beyaz tercihi çok uygun olmuş bence.
Bir de diagnal hareketi çok güzel yerleştirmişsiniz

elinize gözünüze sağlık

nevra

  • Great 
  • delkoo Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 4059 W: 239 N: 5381] (26521)
  • [2008-01-03 4:43]

hi korkut,
I love the framing of your picture... very unusual and very successful.The frame is flawless as you have captured everything in the proper way.it couldn't have been better framed with the solid man in black on thE FG.

wonderful one


BEST REGARDS
DIDIER

Hi Korkut,
Fantastic shot with splendid POV. Excellent choice the B&W and the composition is refined and spectacular. Creative and original work, Congratulations my friend. Have a nice day
George

merhaba sevgili korkut
çok ilginç ve güzel bir bakış açısı.siyah beyaz komposizyonu güçlendirmiş.tebrikler.
ailenle beraber sağlıklı ve sevgi dolu yeni bir yıl temenni ederim.sevgilerimle.
gürkan akçakır.

Excellent shot, the stairs are amazing, your pov is grat for bringing up the details and the composition well chosen.
TFS and a happy new year,
Ioana

  • Great 
  • hergi Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 720 W: 76 N: 310] (5403)
  • [2008-01-03 5:11]

Selamlar,
Ağir ağir çikacak sın zaman merdiveninden , 30 dan sonra dahamı hızlı geçiyor zaman :). Enteresan bir bakış açısı ve kadraj...
Ellerine sağlık
Hülya

Geia sou bostani mou!

Once again your pesimistic mood, but if it's going to lead you to great works of art as this one, let it be! Congratulations!

The Giritli

  • Great 
  • jasmis Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2933 W: 618 N: 3240] (40241)
  • [2008-01-03 5:42]

Real hit. Smashing idea and incredible result.
Superb.
Regards!

Merhaba Korkut,
Farklı bakışla,dik kadrajda Merdivenin kıvrımları çok daha çarpıcı görünüyor.S/B çalışma, tarihi özelliği vurgulamış,merdiveni kullanan İnsan faktörüde olunca dört dörtlük fotoğraf olmuş.Eline sağlık.Ben en çok İntro daki oğuluşunun yeni fotoğrafını sevdim,en şeker zamanıdır şimdi Allah bağışlasın.Selamlar
setenay

  • Great 
  • Faros Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 210 W: 16 N: 305] (3829)
  • [2008-01-03 7:21]

Hi Korkut,
A masterpiece to began the New Year !

Phil.

  • Great 
  • TopGeo Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2135 W: 76 N: 3155] (14034)
  • [2008-01-03 8:08]

Hi, Merhaba! Korkut! I liked the end of note (Life goes on, Live with it, But me personally, I cannot.) Believe however that with the Patience and the Insistence many we can change, (it is enough we change in in our heart!) and we enjoy the each moment of each our second remainder life, with the good way and the effort! Improbable thought and imprinting,
friendlily
Georgios

  • Great 
  • KKar Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 118 W: 0 N: 76] (486)
  • [2008-01-03 9:13]

Excelent photo Dear Korkut
Great perception of the theme.
Happy new year

  • Great 
  • siolaw Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 3877 W: 394 N: 6770] (23199)
  • [2008-01-03 9:35]

Hi Korkut,
Nice monochrome compo from high POV enhancing the graphism of these strange stairways... I like the grainy, antique feel of this image!
A bit late, but Happy new year to you!
Laurent

  • Great 
  • hyasar Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 821 W: 93 N: 609] (6596)
  • [2008-01-03 10:13]

merhaba Korkut,

your approach on the composition is very professionally. The form of stairs and climbing man are impressive. Of course, bw works very well, too.

best regards,
hakan

Bayım, siz İz Dergisi alır mıydınız? (Mesut Bey'i zahmete sokma. Ocak sayısında verilen takvimin ilk sayfası HCB'nin Comondo fotoğrafı)

Orada bu kadar tepeden bir çekim almak için boy ve kol avantajından başka bir şeyler yapmış olman gerekiyor ki, yine bir yerlere tünemiş olmandan (veya dar bir kesimden) şüpheleniyorum. Dernek için oralara gidip gidip de şimdiye dek burayı fotoğraflamamana şaşıyordum zaten.

Tek kelimeyle süper, şaşırtıcı ve hayranlık verici. İz'de yayınlansa şaşmazdım, öyle diyim...

Merhaba,
Benim bildigim 3 olduk HCB anisina burada calisan. Bir Theme yapsak mi ?

Iz dergisi alalim, ama HCB'nin fotografi surada var.

Sevgili Recep Yuksel'in bir fotografi var, hatta cekerken birlikteydik ama 800 fotografi arasinda simdi bulamadim.

Benimki ise burada

Bu en guzeli olmus, HCB dahil :)

Sevgiler.

Hi Korkut,
This place must be full of great opportunities for photography. Fantastic photo!
I love the sharpness, the contrast and the bit of motion blur.
TFS!
Cheers,
Marci

Bonsoir Korkut
félicitation pour cette photo. Le POV me plait beaucoup et la conversion n&b est superbe. Très beau graphisme et grande photo.
Xavier

Merhaba Korkutummm :)

Universite yillarinda Kuledibinde bir apartmanin cati katinda kaliyor ve hergun bu merdivenleri kullaniyordum... yillar oncesine goturdugun icin tesekkurler...
Bakis acin, kadrajdaki amcanin varligi ve renk tercihi muthis... tebrikler

hasan

  • Great 
  • dilane Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 706 W: 151 N: 1201] (9845)
  • [2008-01-03 12:54]

Bonsoir Korkut
C'est excellent, et dans la composition et dans le traitement- vraiment excellent - bravo !
mes meilleurs voeux pour 2008
amicalement
daniel

Yine bakmışsınız tepeden tepeden:) Model de siyah beyaz fotoğraf için biçilmiş kaftan olmuş (saç rengi itibariyle). Not ise, yine duygularıma tercüman. Elinize sağlık.

Talking about sebinho's style this one for sure has korkut's style and touch.
Hi Korkut and first all my wishes for this new year and to all of your family, soon will be first spring for your little youngstar :)
Tremendous BW here, love the contrasts here, the sharpness and details ... but all that serves the terrific play of lines and curves your found here.
Really great one

Quite simply. Stunning! Graphically those stairs have so much potential, and you have exploited it to the full. The POV is perfection. And to capture a guy with white hair dressed in black must have been to good to be true.

Marvelous, Roberto

  • Great 
  • stego Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 3718 W: 620 N: 5223] (16672)
  • [2008-01-03 14:40]

Merhaba Korkut,
I appreciate much these compos made using the visual arrangements of lines and not so usual POV's and this one is specially achieved. It entices our imagination and makes us meditate about life, of possible messages that can be read, who knows... The B&W is very appropriate to the subject.
Selamlar, José.

  • Great 
  • gary91 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2163 W: 492 N: 3238] (14691)
  • [2008-01-03 21:21]

Hello Korkut,
A very original and well thought composition. The person is very cleverly placed and the b&w conversion is great.
I am just wondering what kind of equipment you are using ?
Wish you all the best for this new year 2008.
Best regards, Christian

Korkut tek kelime ile super. Ellerine saglik. SB secimi Kamondo merdivenleri icin olmazsa olmaz gibi zaten. Tebrikler.

Gokhan

  • Great 
  • dip Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 1561 W: 0 N: 937] (9158)
  • [2008-01-04 0:36]

Hi Korkut,
great point of view and excellent B&W choice,nice work of art very well composed!
Regards,
Dimitris.

Merhaba Korkut,
Wow so many curves all around, it's snaking everywhere, love it as well as the inclusion of the person.
Happy New Year !
JY

Hi Korkut - Fantastic POV, the compo is really unusual, attractive, strong, and a message nicely achieved, well done, Daniel

Hi again my friend, what can I write here, a great and very symbolic AND truth.
Cheers
Evangelos

  • Great 
  • drago Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 550 W: 179 N: 808] (4818)
  • [2008-01-04 7:10]

Korkut my friend i wish you a happy New Year!Life goes on,a new year has come,the past one full of memories,life passes very quick!We ought to enjoy every minute!
Cheers and all the best to you and family
Panagiotis

This stairway not only allows you to go up and down but also round and round and in figure of eights - so many patterns of life - I love the way the steps cut in so many different angles and the curve of the man so neatly mirroring the curvature of the stone - a deeply satisfying and artistic image from a photographer who is flying!!!

bw Kev

  • Great 
  • nisko Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 445 W: 78 N: 285] (2425)
  • [2008-01-04 7:39]

dear korkut,i like a lot your creation and the plot of your composition..it was a great idea,well done!
kind regards,
thodoris

Hi Korkut,
beautiful picture with very nice
geometrical schemes and excellent
B&W choice. POV is perfect. Bravo.
Warm regards,
Costantino

  • Great 
  • culp Silver Star Critiquer/Silver Note Writer [C: 43 W: 0 N: 45] (224)
  • [2008-01-04 12:14]

Incredible job. The black and white is wonderful and says so much.
Sincerely
Pamra

  • Great 
  • doubay Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 907 W: 56 N: 922] (4719)
  • [2008-01-04 12:30]

I think this is humiliating… for all those, who have uploaded lots of boring photos of this place in the past. This shot is really excellent, with fantastic geometry and this perfectly fitting white hair guy.
One little remark though: Perhaps it would look even better, if you had left some more space on the left side.
Cheers
Andreas

I really admire your abilty in making these symbolic images. I would love to see inside your head. What comes first? the idea; the poem/lyric; the photo? You forced us into this symbolic reading of the image but lets not forget about the wonderful graphics and the silvery tones. Good work
Kath

Ola Korkut ,
Que interessante composição a preto e barnco com estas escadas com varias drecções, o homem ficou fantastico deu muito movimento a foto , parabens!!!
Um abraço Gonçalo

Hi Korkut,
Splendid captured of the spiral staircase just incorporating the curve rails and stairs ... well composed. Good inclusion of human elements to add dynamics to the scene. Well done! All the best for 2008. tfs
Cheers,
Renier

Bonjour, mon ami Korkut,
Vous êtes un photographe empli de poésie, d'humanité et de talent.
Vos photographies sont pleines de beauté, vous savez regarder notre environnement avec un regard particulier.
Félicitations pour cette photographie très réussie.
Que la Santé vous accompagne tout au long de 2008, que l'Amitié vous côtoie chaque jour, que l'Amour s'installe dans votre demeure et y reste, que la Joie se sème partout où vous passerez .. et surtout .... pensez à partager tout ça autour de vous.
Amitiés.
Philippe

Merhaba,
Nefis bir kare,
kutlarım,
Kemal Mert

Korkut, herkes soylenebilecek herseyi soylemis zaten bana sadece tebrik etmek kaliyor.

Hi Korkut,
A wonderful image of a vertigo feeling...taken from the right point to include the man into the spiral frame.I enjoy it very much file mou...the style of photography I love!

Enjoy your weekend,
Thomas

Korkut, c'est une image bien construite avec cet homme aux cheveux blancs qui monte ces escaliers d'un beau graphisme. Le B&W va très bien au sujet.
Jacques

Korkut,
a shot that puts me into some thinking about life and its different moments and stages. The additional verse that placed here only enhances that feeling and gives the additional element that the New Year with all the resolutions are behind and the reality is starting to kick in.
Cheers, Peter

  • Great 
  • bwiti Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 787 W: 92 N: 1037] (6022)
  • [2008-01-05 13:08]

Magnificent photo! What can I say after all these comments ? Just thousand congratulations and happy new year.... Just it...

merhabalar;
galerinizdeki en güzel karelerden biri..
"The pains will not leave,
I tell myself,
Life goes on
Over and over again."
izninizle favorilerime alıyorum.
ayse

Hello master of graphic,

What's a beautiful photo you have here. The circles look really good here. The man adds another moody feeling in it. Well done.

Thanks for your wishes about my exam. Still struggling with it now :-(

Hello Korkut,
first your note leaved me speechless, as I feel every word of it.
The your image with the man in that strange stair seemed like one in the cycles of life. A simple composition for a great effect, the point of view is powerful and the lighting is great. Bravo.
Kind Regards.
Stella

powerful image...effective use of black and white...creative work...
best wishes, j.

Hello Korkut, fantastic shot! Great composition and POV.

TFS and regards,
Philip

Olá Korkut, love the poem and your picture is outstanding. The fact that they match so well only makes the post even stronger. I feel like God observing this old man going on with his life no matter what. What could he do? He just have to move on, one step at the time...
I wish you all the best for 2008 and specially for the new member of the family ;-)
ricardo

Korkut Bey merhaba,
Nottaki siirle birlikte son derece anlamli bir foto,
Elinize saglik, tebrikler,
Tulay

Merhaba Korkut,
İnsan bazen dakikalarca düşünüp ne yazacağına karar veremiyor, daha doğrusu böyle muhteşem çalışmalara kelime bulamıyor. Ellerine ve yüreğine sağlık...
Selamlar...
Ali Rıza

Ho Korkut!

what a wonderful composition of steps! I notice in your gallery that you have a great eye for stairs, it is really a good background for any subject.
A good quality of BW, a great picture!

Livia

  • Great 
  • ifanik Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1640 W: 52 N: 3031] (16846)
  • [2008-01-06 9:11]

Hi Korkut
Wonderfull picture with beautiful geometry and nice framming
Very good work
Best regards
Nick

Hello Korkut,
Great composition here, and this man in black with white hair fits perfectly on it.
The graphism created by the stairs and their lines is just amazing.
Cheers.
Paulo

  • Great 
  • Paolo Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 4654 W: 146 N: 9145] (40237)
  • [2008-01-06 14:45]

Hi Korkut, wonderufl and brilliant one! the great POV over the man is fantastic and it's the key for this brilliant view.
thanks, ciao

Himmm... Camondo merdivenlerinde Henri Cartier Bresson`dan sonra cekilmis en iyi fotograf....

Tekrar çok artistik ve basarili grafik. 100 tane kritikten sonra diycek bisi yok. Not biraz daha iyi olabilirdi, bu adamin adini hiç duymadim, hem yahudi hemde çinli galiba adindan anlasilirsa.

Hi korkut
Very nice black and white composition. Excellent POV and details. I like the graphism created by the stairs
TFS and greetings
Aires

Merhaba korkut.

I'm still checking the pictures I missed in TE and that's one of the best I've seen.

Excellent POV and contrasts too!

Rgs, Oscar

  • Great 
  • vincz Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2964 W: 85 N: 5038] (17528)
  • [2008-01-07 0:44]

Excellent compostion. I just wonder if you saw the potential when looking at the stairs from that POV, then waited for an interesting subject to pass by. The result is excellent.

Fantastic PoV for this Escheresque composition, Korkut, very symbolic photo featuring your favorite element - stairs, the symbolism is strengthened by the fact that we do not see the person's face...

Cheers and happy new year!
Alexander

Merhaba Korkut,

Orijinal bir kompozisyon, ak saçli bey çok yakismis bu kareye, ve fotograf makinesine degil, yere asagiya bakmasi güzel olmus. Daha iyi bir "mystery" yaratiyor.

Selam ve saygilar, Korkut.

Bülent

üstad,
söyleyecek bir şey yok..
Fevkalade..
tebrik,
Sevgi, saygı
Murat

Hello Korkut
great picture!! B&W is right, composition is wonderful...very very well done

Alessandro

MERHABALAR KORKUT BY:)
ESKİ TÜRK FİLMERİNDEN BİR KARE GİBİ ELİNİZE SAĞLIK...

En güzel resimlerinden biri olmuş. Pencereden mi sarktın? Eline sağlık.

  • Great 
  • AmiBe Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 2066 W: 370 N: 1681] (19514)
  • [2008-01-10 9:33]

Hi Korkut,
nice curves, good POV from above... these stairs are wonderful.
Maybe the man takes too much place in the picture for my taste.
rgs

Bakış açısı,Siyah/beyaz tercihi ve amcanın ifadesi ile çok hoş ve etkili bir fotoğraf.
Ellerinize sağlık
Selamlar

  • Great 
  • Anna-- Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 651 W: 58 N: 295] (5610)
  • [2008-01-11 10:19]

Ciao Korkut,
a superb one! Great tribute to HCB, I like the high contrast and the wonderful framing and capture.
Anna

  • Great 
  • mikeo Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1245 W: 94 N: 1466] (9868)
  • [2008-01-13 6:14]

Korkut,

This is superb! Composition, POV and b/w colours are unbelievable! Perfect shot with great note.

Greetings
Aga

merhaba,
cok guzel bır calısma. grafık etkisi, komp., bakış açısı ve renk tercıhı cok basarılı. SB kontrastı da cok etkılı. tebrık ederım
selamlar
şaban

  • Great 
  • nes7 Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Note Writer [C: 72 W: 1 N: 23] (502)
  • [2008-01-13 16:00]

İhmal ettiğim karelerden biri. "Ağır ağır çıkacaksın bu merdivenlerden" dizelerini çağrıştıran, uzun uzun bakınca insanı düşüncelere daldıran duygusal bir paylaşım olmuş... Merdivenlerin hepsini çıkıp merdivenlerde bitince asıl final orda sanırsam, süpriz ki ne süpriz. Her merdivenin hakkını vermek, her şeyi iyi yaşamak gerek:)))) FİNAL DE GÜZEL OLSUN DEĞİL Mİ?

It's really amazing how good you are my friend to see details.
Here the combination from the stairs lines and the climbing man, send to us the message you want to send.
Excellent the B/W conversion, gives something melancholic to all composition that suits very good with the words from the poem.
Very good work filaraki.
Best regards
Kostas

Excellent picture Korkut,

Very courageous frame, and nothing here spoils the subject that you had in mind the Camondo stairs and a passing person only - Izzet

How to complete a masterpiece, your image is a beautiful example of that, compliments Korkut, great perspective, B&W and excellent inclusion of the old man, your POV is amazing, well done.
Ciao
Vinicio

  • Great 
  • kipli Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 128 W: 2 N: 194] (1007)
  • [2008-01-19 2:27]

Fantastico scatto!
Grandissimo punto di vista e ottima scelta del bianco e nero.
Complimenti!

Ciao
Andrea

Not much to comment
Very original photo and idea :)

a piece of art no needs nothing else..just the admiring view..!!!!

gngrs kardasi

Nikiforos

dear Korkut, how are you? are you fine? and your family?
the image is really good! with a wonderful game of stairs..
great high perspective too!
bravooo!
ciao!
Valeria

Superb work, Korkut... my God, I have missed out on so much... this is incredible and to me also somewhat "personal" as the man walking upstairs reminds me of my favourite, now deceased poet in Hungary, Pilinszky. The work's stark bw symbolism is poignant, the moment perfectly captured, Korkut. Into my second batch of favs.
Take care,
sasa

Hi Korkut,

Interesting shot with the high POV. The B&W is a good idea and the curves and lines of the stairs please me ! Good work.

And thanks a lot for your nice comment...

Regards,
Stéphanie.

  • Great 
  • euryan Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1120 W: 124 N: 1827] (8014)
  • [2008-02-11 11:46]

First of all the B&W is just great here. Each stair has a full range of tones and contrast. Compositionally this is very interesting. The unique perspective of looking straight down on this man gives a strange feeling. The curving staircases fill the frame very artistically. His black clothes make him stand out too.
Life goes on. We must keep climbing until we reach the top.

you do have an excellent eye for looking at patterns & your way of composing is worthy of commendations...
I liked your sticking to the basic B&W form also
the POV & usage of top angle created magic on the canvas :)
well done

Hi Korkut,

this is a magic shot! The stairs architecture is surprising like in a MC Escher painting. The human presence adds a misteryous mood. Perfect composition and POV, good B/W choice and contrast.

Well done!

Gio

Hi Korkut. Great point of view! I like the way you combine all the geometric lines of the stairs with the silhouette of the guy. Excellent crop and very good choice for B&W. Regards, Yvonne

  • Great 
  • danyy Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 7609 W: 448 N: 10764] (54770)
  • [2008-02-16 15:54]

Bonjour Korkut,
quelle fantastique galerie, je viens de la parcourir, peu de photos ne me plaisent pas. J'aime beaucoup celle ci pour son graphisme évident, ses courbes qui contiennent des droites, le traitement n/b qui convient bien et ce personnage idéalement placé.
Best regards.
Daniel.

  • Great 
  • erel Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 814 W: 0 N: 371] (10225)
  • [2008-04-22 23:31]

MERHABA
BRAVOOOOOOOOOOOOO...EREL

  • Great 
  • MayaG Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 274 W: 15 N: 397] (2177)
  • [2008-05-15 4:52]
  • [+]

If there was a collection to be made of best shots on TE ever, my suggestion would be to include this one...especially with this title, you do know how to make your images complete by giving them a meaning. I don't know if you had the chance to 'meet' online the work of a Portuguese photographer (an amateur), Rui Palha? I admire his B&W photos, and this image instantly reminded me of him...trust me, that's the biggest complement I could ever give to anyone!
warm regards
Marija

  • Great 
  • Isa-M Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Silver Note Writer [C: 229 W: 36 N: 14] (2501)
  • [2008-06-23 19:45]

Korkut...
what can I say ?
amazing art with your soul and heart inside....
Isabela

it s great,i love it...
eline sağlık.
Tamer

  • Great 
  • ryno Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 759 W: 0 N: 197] (3772)
  • [2008-08-08 8:34]

Hi Korkut, this is a very evocative shot of one of my favourite parts of Istanbul. Perhaps you know this, but Henri Cartier-Bresson's 1938 photo of this same staircase was used as the Penguin cover for Albert Camus' novel "The Outsider". Your shot captures something of that same quality. Great POV (taken from the window of the pharmacy above this place?)
Regards, Ryno

  • Great 
  • avene Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1452 W: 80 N: 1837] (6908)
  • [2008-09-26 9:27]

hello Korkut,
this shot is too good to pass by without leaving my 2 cents :) the Escher-esque stairs were the first to attract my attention, then the note, then the combination of the photo and the poem, and now I don't think I can write a meaningful comment. simple, but very powerful image, life does indeed goes on, up and down and in many different directions, as the stairs here. I do like that the man is climbing UP :) superb work, my compliments.

best,
Kristine

Yes, another jewel in your portfolio. What can one say? BW gives an exceptional tone. Very wise choice. Good eye.
Stainless.
Nikos

Hey Anna
i just love the asymmetry in the photograph. its kinda like the human mind, twisted all throughout! just love the black clothed person amist all the white.
take care
ciao

Calibration Check
















0123456789ABCDEF