Vienna 2004

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Martine (0)
• [2004-08-04 8:43]

très bon choix du N&B ! on est enntre de plein fouet dans l'époque Victorienne. Très bien vu.

•  
• claudiaf (4305)
• [2004-08-04 9:19]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• akeyswede (985)
• [2004-08-04 9:46]

Nice use of the black and white to strenthen the sence of history and timelessness.

•  
• sn00zie (2382)
• [2004-08-04 11:32]

wow! a brilliant b/w composition... the pictures crystal clear... simply love your subject!

•  
• softflower (0)
• [2004-08-04 14:16]

Joli cliché en N&B, on se croirait revenu en arrière.
Félicitations Ioan.

•  
• harold (2267)
• [2004-08-04 14:49]

Très jolie image en noir et blanc qui nous font faire un petit bon en arrière la photo est très net bravo ioan.amitié harold

•  
• centurion (0)
• [2004-08-04 15:55]

Beautiful B/W picture sugerating old good times. It could also be 100 years ago. Good composition, and good idea for make it in black and white only.

•  
• ma-tibou (4566)
• [2004-08-06 6:58]

Très belle réalisation Ioan, image intemporelle, es-tu sûr de la date? rire!!! très bonne idée justement le noir et blanc. Bravo.

•  
• Jeppe (18564)
• [2004-08-06 12:41]

Very fine composition you with the statue and carrige - perhaps did you crop a bit to much at the left side.
I like however - thanks Ioan.

•  
• orme (6613)
• [2004-08-08 22:42]

A good composition, Ioan. Good choice of B/W. I think the photo needs more space on the left and tilted slightly to the right.

•  
• gbac (1931)
• [2004-08-09 4:11]
• [2]

Très bonne idée de faire ce cliché en N&B. Par contre il aurait été bien d'élargir un peu le cadrage car les chevaux buttent contre le cadre (manque d'espace devant eux).
Bien vu Ioan

•  
• agpires (0)
• [2004-08-09 8:54]

Beautiful realization in black and white, there is just in the composition an element which disturbs me, that is the horses which ridge on the left edge of the photograph, it would have been preferable that the barouche moves from left to right, for to have a splendid image.

•  
• Rinie_Hoff (9316)
• [2004-08-11 10:46]

Hi Ioan, good choice to convert this picture in B&W, gives an idea if times, long gone, and that fits the image.
The only thing that I don't like so much, is that the horses are walking out of the frame instead of into the frame. If you had composed it woith the carriage on the right side of the picture, you would have had a much stronger picture.

•  
• kourosh (2356)
• [2004-08-11 10:52]

nice composition. slightly oversharpened for my taste though. the choice of black and white suits very well. good shot.

•  
• hdl (6276)
• [2004-08-12 6:39]

Nice picture and good in B&W. You could as well have used "Vienna 1804" as title. Nevertheless, I must agree with Kaj. It would have been better to give the horses some space to move.

•  
• yesterday (9698)
• [2004-08-13 2:47]

Good B/W, light and contrast is good, the composition is not so good, it is to tight crop in the left side, and it have been better, if the photo was taken, then the horse was on the way into pic. insted of the way out.
Last thing, the photo should have been rotatet a bit to the right.

I give 1 point, you have to wait, out fore today.

regards Kaj Nielsen

•  
• maphoto (8074)
• [2004-08-19 11:04]

Hi Ioan, a great choice for a B&W photo, very nice scene, maybe just add a little space in front of the horses and it would be perfect, well presented, thanks for sharing.

•  
• playwrought (98)
• [2004-08-19 12:53]

Gorgeous shot. The contrast here is absolutely perfect, which is terrific especially for being your first B&W shot. I usually prefer that the subject does not butt up against the frame so closely, but this does not bother me here. Well done.

•  
• erthmuffin (1408)
• [2004-08-19 12:54]

good choice in black and white! well composed, nice tones! it looks very old, with the old carriage and builing.

•  
• robiuk (10438)
• [2004-08-26 6:00]

Hey, Ioan,
Very good considering it is your first b/w work. Bravo!
May I suggest taking b/w photos of places in Romania - as I think these would be great!?
Romania is supposed to be very beautiful country, so please more photos from there!
;-D

•  
• nwoehnl (60423)
• [2004-08-30 13:58]

Good result for your first b&w, Ioan. It does enhance the "classical" look of the horse carriage going in front of the old Viennese architecture. A bit tight on the left; ideally the horses would have a little more space to breathe (and to pull the carriage into). Lovely setting though, thanks for sharing.

•  
• loupiot (3905)
• [2004-09-13 5:30]

Joli cliché N&B, Ioan! C'est une très bonne idée, nous avons l'impression de faire un bond en arrière dans le temps. Bien vu!

•  
• Bogdan (1608)
• [2004-11-02 4:46]
• [+]

Hei, e buna. Nu pare prima b&w.. :) Imi place mult incdrarea, chiar spune multe. O singura problema..trasura e prea in dreapta imaginii, si pare ca e taiata de cadru. E bine ca ai incadrat-o asa, pt. ca da impresia de miscare..cativa mm in plus, in fata trasurii ar fi facut-o grozava.

Bogdan.

P.S. : Cum iti mai e?

•  
• CrissX (1093)
• [2005-01-23 2:58]

Trasura e in stanga... si mi se pare bine incadrata.Ai surprins foarte bine atmosfera din anii 1800.Faptul ca e si B&W e si mai bine.. pe atunci nu existau "culorile".

•  
• Cath (360)
• [2005-01-24 13:24]

Utilisation du noir et blanc très judicieuse.Netteté de la photo puis cette calèche nous plonge ds le passé. Belle composition.Amicalement Catherine