Photographer’s Note
This is the second photo of a hand-rickshaw puller I have added to my gallery; The first of which I added about a month ago.
This was not a posed shot, but I noticed the rickshaw puller watching me as I made my way down the side-street and getting closer to where he was sat. I was intending to photograph him but also wished he hadn't noticed me first. I wanted a natural shot of him relaxing but I could see it was too late now. As I got to him I was still debating whether or not I was going to take his picture but he already knew the answer: He adjusted his position ready for his turn and gave me a big smile. I guess he just knew how photogenic he was!
I am not sure what this proud and friendly man is doing to survive now. Whether his life is better or worse. Whether he is still working as a hand-rickshaw puller or whether he has a new job; a better job; a future...
Only 2 weeks after I left the dusty streets of Kolkata and indeed India behind, a law was passed to phase out hand-pulled rickshaws in this fascinating city.
The following is an excerpt from the BBC World News dated Monday December 4th, 2006:-
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Kolkata's famous hand-pulled rickshaws will soon be banned, according to the chief minister of the Indian state of West Bengal.
The rickshaws had long been considered "inhuman" and did not exist anywhere else, Buddhadev Bhattacharya said.
The hand-pulled rickshaw came from China in the 19th century.
Mr Bhattacharya said: "We have taken a policy decision to take the hand-drawn rickshaw off the roads of Kolkata on humanitarian grounds.
"Nowhere else in the world does this practice exist and we think it should also cease to exist in Kolkata," he said.
The chief minister said the authorities were thinking of alternative modes of transport so that the transition did not affect either the pullers or the riders.
"This involves money and training. It will be about the end of this year when the rickshaws are finally gone," he said.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The government goes on to mention introducing a "rehabilitation package" for rickshaw drivers to train them for other jobs but I don't know whether this been implemented or whether most of these people are now forgotten and jobless.
The average earnings of a rickshaw puller is around 100 rupees ($2.25) a day. Most sleep, eat and live on the city's crowded pavements.
Many are poor people from states neighbouring West Bengal. In most cases they do not own the vehicles, but pay a sizeable portion of their earnings to hire them.
I do not know what it is like now but when I was there these rickshaws were still a common sight in the city. They were especially in demand during the monsoon when flooded streets make it hard for commuters to use taxis or cars.
PP details: Full-frame shot, no cropping; Minimal brightness/contrast correction; Black frame added.
Regards,
Rich
indoka28, crckt, happypoppeye, Hellas has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
eskay001
(106) 2007-07-11 12:33
Dear Richard, I found the photo and the accompanying note very likable. Such man-pulled rickshaw were popular in Mussoorie (Dehra Dun, Uttaranchal, India) also and served to provide livelyhood to many people. However, as soon as a self-righteous Prime Minister saw them, his heart started bleeding for the poor men pulling these rickshaw and he immediately ordered a complete ban on this means of transport. The result? All the rickshaw pullers in Mussorie had to sell their means of livelyhood as a fuel. If it is banned, what good it is for except burning as fuel. That great politician and the humanitarian did not think twice about what will happen to the families of these pullers.
ohe
(2332) 2007-07-11 12:36
Dear Richard,
Very nice shot !! Great note !
This is part of the daily life and I like the way your subject reacts, being proud of what he's doing!
Life is sometimes 'simple' in such countries!
Thanks for sharing,
- Olivier -
indoka28
(5183) 2007-07-11 20:41
Hello Rich,
This is the best portrait of a rickshaw puller in TE I guess...theis is the first time I am not feeling sad looking at a rickshaw puller whose lives are so much shrowded in misery..!!!
A very beautiful composition with a kind of happiness which is being generated from his smile that makes me smile also..!! I loved the way you have positioned the man and his vehicle..I liked the colours very much and the clarity is very good..!!! not to forget the note...wow..!!! too good..!! I loved it..
Keep posting ..!!!
crckt
(7072) 2007-07-12 13:32
Hi Rich,
He does have a very photogenic face. You captured a nice shot.
Well done,
Shaeri
ben4321
(9781) 2007-07-22 9:58
This is a really good portrait of this man Richard, he looks totally at ease relaxing on his rickshaw and you captured his expression very well.
I like how you included the whole of the rickshaw, although perhaps the shot would have benefited from tighter framing at the top to cut down on some of the empty space there.
Other than that, it's very well taken - a top notch environmental portrait.
It's sad that in India's rush towards modernisation many of these people will fall by the wayside, but with his confidence and good nature I'm sure this guy won't be among them!
Good work.
Cheers,
Ben
happypoppeye
(4060) 2007-07-24 9:12
Another great portrait of a rick shaw puller Rich.
This is really a great photo. Composition is perfect. Color and exposure are as well. The man's expression is great along with his position on the rickshaw. He just looks so relaxed and the whole photo looks natural. It, sort, makes me think that the government is more unhappy with the situation than the rickshaw pullers are - or maybe with just this particular one.
Great work. This is really good.
John
Hellas
(5117) 2007-09-10 1:49
Hello Richard,
this portrait is very good. It was a good choice to capture this man with his working means. He seems to be unaware of the problem that a few days later would have happened. I hope evrything to be o.k. for the man, now! A great moment! Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Athanasios.
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Richard Mayneord (richwm)
(1209) - Genre: People
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2006-11-23
- Categories: Daily Life, Transportation
- Camera: Canon EOS-30D, Canon EF 28-135mm f/3.5-5.6 IS USM
- Exposure: f/6.3, 1/125 seconds
- More Photo Info: view
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Date Submitted: 2007-07-11 12:05








