Photographer’s Note
A Day in London – Page 10
The Burghers of Calais
A sculpture symbolising the epitomy of civic sacrifice, Auguste RODIN’s ‘The Burghers of Calais’ was purchased as a copy by the British government in 1911 and placed in the Victoria Palace Gardens next to the Palace of Westminster (the seat of the British Parliament) in 1915. A symbolic act in the time of the Great War. I came to photograph this partly because I knew the story and partly because many years ago a sculptor friend snuck into the gardens in the early hours of the morning and took a cast of his favourite burgher’s head! I’d never made the effort to see it before. It’s amazing to think that this scene is almost 100% what someone would have seen from this spot and angle 90 years ago.
The sculpture commemorates an incident in the Hundred Years War between the English and the French. In 1347, the city of Calais was besieged by the English, led by King Edward III. Edward demanded the surrender of the city. To stop any further loss of life, the oldest Burgher, Eustache de Saint Pierre, led a group of six (here I photograph four of them) of Calais' leading citizens to the English. However, thanks to the intervention of Edward's pregnant wife, Phillippa, who had braved the journey to be with her husband, the lives of all six Burghers were spared.
Their willingness to sacrifice themselves for the benefit of the populace is an act of bravery which acts as a symbolic reminder to our civic leaders of what such leadership might ultimately require.
It is such values, despite the erosions of time and fashion, which have shaped commonalities in our European past and which, when you study such stories of sacrifice the world over - beyond our Eurocentric viewpoints, you can recognise in people of true honour everywhere. These are not the kind of people who would suffer the killing of an innocent bystander but would rather lay their own lives on the line, with fear perhaps, but also with some inner dignity to benefit the greatest good. There is nothing heroic about this statue, the men look downcast, under pressure and in some despair – it is intensely sad and human but they have chosen to do something of the most rare value for their fellow human beings.
Rodin always wanted this sculpture to be presented at ground level but here it is on a pedestal, I really think the artist’s wishes should be respected.
RGatward, nerve, designsoul, bantonbuju, Fixfocus, manss0fl has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
RGatward
(19749) 2005-09-20 4:36
Wel found PoV to illustrate this interesting statue, good tech all round.
Furachan
(0) 2005-09-20 4:37
This is just dandy, Kev. Here's what I see:
1. The tilt -cool and justified
2. Both subjects made to appear the same size
3. One WHITE, one BLACK
4. Top notch B/W tonalities
5. Superb note to give it all context.
A++ as Luan would say...
Bravo!
Kindest,
Francis
cessy
(13647) 2005-09-20 5:59
very nice angle and composition
the black and white
the statue and the buildings
very good gradation of grey color in background
well done
nerve
(10212) 2005-09-20 8:13
this is a great shot Kev, very artistic..
i love your composition, your POV.. B/W tones have a top-notch quality in this..
Beautiful piece of work really, congratulations!
tk.
designsoul
(21394) 2005-09-20 10:23
Wonderful shot of contrasting tones and exquisite composition, Kev, a piece of art, with meaning. Your note is excellent, the juxtaposition of Rodin's sculpture with the Westminster Abbey is very masterfully done. And yes, I agree: of course the Burghers should be on the ground.
Sarolta
gaby
(19793) 2005-09-20 11:28
Hi Kev wonderful black and fantastic white - all is great in this shot -
splendid
Thanks
Gaby
bantonbuju
(48796) 2005-09-20 11:35
i knew it: kev's version of london wouldn't be somehow ordinary, faceless chain of pop postcards, insted - it'd be something of an artistic great value, accompanied by the unveiled stories of real value either artistic or historical, or cultural, or social; it is a pleasure to visit the city with you, kev;
and what you say in the note, the thing about dignity and honour, is deeply toutching;
tc! j.
entrelec
(8342) 2005-09-20 11:49
Sorry, i come after the battle, all have been said; i like much this shot, amazing black against white...
joel
Fixfocus
(9377) 2005-09-20 12:04
Hi Kev,
Well composed with the included tower and the main subject in the right corner.Strong graphism here so B/W was the best choice.
Greetings,
hermann
bullabulla
(3488) 2005-09-20 13:53
Hey Kev!
Great shot good W&B great note
you should come in paris one day visiting Rodin's house and you will see the real
"Burghers of Calais " I don't know if it is your picture but the real one don't seem that impressive !
Thanks for that
Laetitia
dolin
(15647) 2005-09-20 14:40
Hi Kev.
Excellent idea of utilization of these 2 parts.
The pov and the framing are very good for me.
I like how you have framed this statue on the border and the perfect dof fot this bulding.
The contrast of these 2 parts is excellent too.
Impressive gray sky...good job.
Fred
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Kev Ryan (KevRyan)
(22418) - Genre: Places
- Medium: Black & White
- Date Taken: 2005-09-08
- Categories: Architecture
- Camera: Canon EOS 10D
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Theme(s): Your Favourites [view contributor(s)]
- Date Submitted: 2005-09-20 4:18
- Favorites: 1 [view]
Discussions
- To dolin: Chess (1)
by KevRyan, last updated 09-21 07:30 - To bantonbuju: I'm so happy.... (6)
by KevRyan, last updated 09-21 03:38 - To Furachan: like a giant chess board! (1)
by KevRyan, last updated 09-20 17:59 - To designsoul: Hi sarolta (1)
by KevRyan, last updated 09-20 15:59 - To bullabulla: Rodin's House (1)
by KevRyan, last updated 09-20 15:23








