Decisions, Decisions

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• alainh (31888)
• [2005-07-07 10:00]

hello Matt,
splendid light in this historic reconstitution. a good shot.
regards
alain

•  
• weswang (18223)
• [2005-07-07 10:51]

Hi Matt, A nice acting. I kind of feel this is a series of shooting picture here. Thanks for the continuity of the stories. A nice portrait and beautiful scenery.

•  
• Tue (23875)
• [2005-07-07 17:29]

Hi Matt,
A nice series about this battle it is! I like this picture of those two men again too.
Well done!
Groetjes,
Lars

•  
• erdna (4929)
• [2005-07-08 11:23]
• [+]

TFS the series Matt. After seeing the pictures, I think this is the sharpest photo (Is it because it is in RAW format?)but I like the action of "Hot Work" photo. You have done well in documenting this re-enactment of an historical event.

Andre'

•  
• john_c (24618)
• [2005-07-09 12:49]

Hey Matt, this is becoming an intriguing series. Truly enjoyable the way you are capturing these various scenes in a colourful and yet natural, unposed manner. The clarity of this shot is outstanding. I am going to have to try some RAW shooting sometime. Very well done, learned friend.
John

•  
• jmdaoudal (18662)
• [2005-07-11 6:40]

I can see that this is a true representation from,the french "élégance".
I like very much this topic you post, well framed and coloured.
If photography had existed in these times it would have been just like this, whitout the ear protection for the left man :)))
Montcalm is famous in our history, but we finished by loosing this one against the English, otherwise you would speak french in your country:))))
Compliments
Jean Michel

•  
• supereira (9576)
• [2005-07-12 5:08]

I like the composition and point of view.Very good colors,light and sharpness.I like the expression of the men.Well done!

•  
• PixelTerror (73872)
• [2005-07-12 6:28]
• [+]

Hi Matt,
Jean-Michel wrote about elegance, yeah for sure these guys are good examples of a disappeared military elegance, your catch of the scene is great too here with the grey one evaluating the situation and the blue one looking at him expecting the command, this sets the hierarchy at once. ABout framing, I believe I would have preferred to see them in full. Great photo quality in terms of light, sharpness, colors and clarity.
Have a nice day,
Jean-Yves

•  
• Steft (5958)
• [2005-07-12 19:20]

Nice photo, this is a bit like a scene of a film. I like that fact that you were quite close to this people, so that we can see them quite clearly. The water in the background is a beautiful add.

•  
• Mishe (3495)
• [2005-07-13 6:41]

Hi Matt!
Very interesting photo.Very well done.
Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Mishe.

•  
• capthaddock (28303)
• [2005-07-15 10:20]

Hi Matt - these reenactments look very interesting, this one is excellent because I see nothing modern in this frame.

•  
• elihesamian (25819)
• [2005-07-18 3:52]

Oh!
officers!
They are thinking for another action!
Great used of DOF and very well captured with ecellent details and colors,well composed,too,and I like the real pose of all them here,nicely done,Matt!
Best
M

•  
• Nikofan (1080)
• [2006-07-07 17:09]

Very nice historical shot.
They look asking themselves : keep the Brits or not?

Bernard