Photographer’s Note
I had a tip from Chris Chafer (Sandpiper) last July, that the Carrington Falls in Budderoo National Park was looking good, with better flow than he had seen for some time. A few days later I checked it out for myself, and almost a year later I’m finally posting it.
Carrington Falls are a couple of hours drive south of Sydney, (about 120 km). They are a pretty falls, dropping about 50 metres. The final leg of the trip to them is interesting. There is an extremely steep climb (by car) out of the Kangaroo Valley to get to the top. The road is narrow with a couple of hairpin turns. I found holding ones breath on the drive up helps. To finally arrive at the falls you drive across a small low wooden bridge. This bridge is actually just back of the falls a little way. If the trees on the right at the top weren’t in the shot you would see it. Once there, the falls have some interesting trails around them and a couple of different spots to view them. I took this picture straight out from the car parking area (the second one from the falls).
I tried a couple of different things at this one. It is a reasonably tall falls, falling into a dark canyon so I thought I would try an HDR, and a tall Panoramic along with some basic reference shots.
The HDR file I was putting together was disastrous. I took 5 shots for it. The longest exposure of 2 seconds I scrapped immediately for blur in the trees on the right. When I assembled the others this blur between the shots was apparent again. I scrapped a 1 second exposure shot during the processing and ended up with 3. The end product just didn’t look good so I scrapped that project, lesson learned; HDR doesn’t work if there is any wind at all.
I also tried a tall Panorama. I shot it a shade under exposed at f27 ½ second. I assembled it (manually) and ended up cropping out about a third of it. I had white sky which didn’t add any value. So in the end I have this (not quite so tall) shot, which I was reasonably happy with.
Some of this from: http://www.southcoast.com.au/southernhighlands/attractions.html#Carring
Workflow for this shot was as follows:
2 Shots were taken in RAW with jpegs for reference and processed together
Both were shot at ISO 200 29mm @f27, ½ sec
I added (extended) canvas to the 1st one, large enough to hold the second file
I copied the second file and pasted onto the larger canvas
I flipped the canvas 90 degrees and zoomed in to help with the alignment.
I used the manual transform tool on the new 2nd layer to adjust size and angle for perfect fit.
Once I was happy with the alignment I added a layer mask to the upper layer and brushed the edge with a 50% opacity black brush to ensure seamless blending
Rotated back to perpendicular, rotated to straight and cropped to present format
Work could progress now as if it was a normal shot
Adjusted levels – black points and midpoints (by eye)
Adjusted curves – used auto, then tweeked by eye from there – pulled highlights down a bit, for the sky (which I later cropped out anyway)
Added an overlay layer and dodged and burned with 5-10% opacity black and white brush
Added saturation layer +25 to master -30 to yellow
Saved as a tiff
Resized, added a layer for sharpening with USM, modified sharpening with a layer mask (40% black brush), mostly toned down the water and the trees on the right, framed and saved as a jpeg.
migzal, mvdisco, Matthew-Watt, Dyerco, ktanska, edytungkal, skippy007, MLINES, crhieatt, Waylim, jusninasirun, Rosa, pboehringer, pierrefonds, bakes888, shevchenko has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
migzal
(485) 2008-04-01 19:53
Hi John,
Thank for the note. This is the first time i've heard about HDR and i would be eager to try it with care not loosing the sense realism of the image.
mvdisco
(11466) 2008-04-01 20:52
Hi John,
Nice composition of the Carrington falls, Excellent POV. and details of the falls, well taken picture with a low speed that made a great portrait of this falls, good colors and sharpness, nice naturel framing with the tree, very well done..
Michel
Matthew-Watt
(4463) 2008-04-01 22:50
Hello John,
An excellent photo, this combination of settings, through trial and error, has paid off for you. The silky water looks dramatic as it makes its way over the edge and into the valley floor below. The foliage has moved little within the 1/2 second exposure, and there are no burnt out sections to detract either. It is very pleasant to see a decent amount of water tumbling over these falls. Sydney has a huge amount of natural vegetation surrounding it, just look at it through Google Earth! It is a great natural asset to the people of the city and all its visitors.
Matt
Dyerco
(9018) 2008-04-01 23:29
Well John
Your finished product looks just great. You captured that silky look to the falls and maintained a good exposure. Well done. I'm glad you left out any sky.
Phil
ktanska
(16524) 2008-04-01 23:39
Hi John,
Beautiful shot of these falls showing typical steep rock edges of that region. All the work to master the brightness differences has clearly paid off. Excellent framing with eucalyptus trees.
Kari
edytungkal
(4519) 2008-04-02 0:56
It has a fantastic point of view with perfect quality, this a very well result with smooth water fall effects. A nice nature colours composes. Thanks John
daniel
skippy007
(6963) 2008-04-02 2:00
Hi John,
This one has your trade mark all over it, Fantastic POV, nice composition, excellent sharpness & light. Your note and workflow is very interesting and informative as always.
Well done.
Regards
Santo
MLINES
(10860) 2008-04-02 6:33
Hi John, Another fine waterfall composition. Your settings were just right to get the effect of the falling water as this shows. Well cropped and excellent notes. TFS. Murray.
Cormac
(26449) 2008-04-02 8:04
Beautiful waterfall! I'm a big fan of waterfalls, so I like this one. The falls are nicely framed between the trees on each side. It would probably be better if the sun was on the waterfall, but it's so bright that we can still see it well. Nice work!
crhieatt
(5143) 2008-04-02 9:15
John,
Fine, delicate and detailed shot of these falls, which despite your lengthy PP listing, ends up looking completely natural - but I guess that's the point!
Regards
Colin
crckt
(7072) 2008-04-02 9:54
Hi John,
Slow shutter is in my opinion the best way to capture a waterfall. You prove exactly my point. Great shot, looks so pretty.
TFS,
Shaeri
Waylim
(10741) 2008-04-02 17:56
John,
Excellent job on this image, and yes, thanks for the very detail pp note. Wow, I don’t think I spend that much time pp my image. I think I should, looking at your image here.
Waterfall is usually more impressive being there in person, but you did great here with this composition. One can really see and imagined its height from your image. Excellent control and balance on the light considering the waterfall is mostly in the shade, you still manage to have such clarity and sharpness yet not overexpose the elements in the sun light. You have my utmost admiration. Thanks for taking your times.
Way
jusninasirun
(10179) 2008-04-02 18:07
Hello John. You made the right choice to post this vertical format in showing us this gorgeous fall. This picture is like a three dimensional image with cleverly composed natural framing. The foliage under the sun and pinning that timber on the bottom right frame is brilliant. The fall under the shade generates a sense of depth and well selected shutter to display the flow and yet superb sharpness of the texture around it. Well done John and it looks to me that the fall is dipping into a very deep well, kinda mysterious here. Best regards. Jusni
Rosa
(4589) 2008-04-03 14:01
Hello John,
Excellent POV,
Tres bon choix pour le cadrage verticale, il nous montre la grandeur de cette belle chute d'eau.
Bravo,
Amitiés,
Rosa.
pboehringer
(770) 2008-04-04 7:23
John,
the shot is good and I just can imagine all the work that you had to get this result until I read your detailed note that gives a most detailed description of your failures. Well, i was always a person that learned more with my errors than with my successes. So, thanks for sharing your frustrations!
Peter
pierrefonds
(26117) 2008-04-05 5:02
Hi John,
A nice image of the Carrington falls, the details and colors of the scenery are clear and precise. The subject is well framed. The capture of the water movement is an asset to the composition. Have a nice day.
Pierre
bakes888
(18129) 2008-04-06 0:46
Hi John. You put a lot of work into this shot, shame you can’t post as a large post. I love the way you have framed it with the trees. Good POV and well composed. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers, Paul.
mumek
(17468) 2008-04-09 13:41
Hi John!
Very beautiful capture of the Carrington Falls.Good quality of the photo, sharp details and nice natural colours. Thanks for the note
regards
ziggy
shevchenko
(9862) 2008-04-10 19:42
Hi John,
Good exposure to capture the pure white waterfall hidden in dim cliff, beautiful foreground young plants shinning in golden sunlight, good pov to include it, thanks for sharing.
Ally
sandpiper
(1579) 2008-06-01 20:25
Hi John
I'm glad to see you finally got there, and quite a good result too. Unfortunately those shrubs have gotten even bigger so unless Parks do some trimming soon, a shot like this won't be possible at all.
I've recently discovered HDR myself and taken some interesting shots - though I haven't posted on TE for ages, too busy on TN.
Anyway, for a sunny day you're technique has worked well, I like it.
cheers
Chris
BWJ
(1771) 2008-06-24 17:42
Hello John,
This is a powerful landscape filled with the motion of the rushing water falling over the rocks. Your POV is excellent and the composition is flawless. This shot is well worth your hard work to get it. It's spectacular!
Warm wishes,
Betty
Photo Information
-
Copyright: John Plumb (JPlumb)
(3153) - Genre: Places
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2007-07-14
- Categories: Nature
- Camera: Nikon D200, Nikkor 18-200mm 3.5-5.6 G ED AF-S VR, Sigma EX Wide Circular PL 72mm
- Exposure: f/27, 1/2 seconds
- Details: Tripod: Yes
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Date Submitted: 2008-04-01 19:15
Discussions
- To pboehringer: Learning More from Our Errors (1)
by JPlumb, last updated 04-04 02:36 - To jusninasirun: There is a River (1)
by JPlumb, last updated 04-03 01:35 - To migzal: HDR (1)
by JPlumb, last updated 04-02 01:27








