Photographer’s Note
Federation Square
Another photo from my trip to Melbourne last week.
PLEASE don’t tell me that the walls are crooked or I should have removed the lines overhead!!
The walls ARE ALL crooked.
The wire lines are attached to the buildings and to each other, as if to hold them upright and all together. And the tubes hanging down from the wires are lights that look like starts at night – they look quite attractive at night.
The story of Federation Square and how it became the landmark it is today involves six hard years and more than 5000 people. Behind every bit of the distinctive triangular façade, every wall, every window, there’s a story of battles, disputes and decisions, as the creative vision of the architects clashed with the demands of time and budget.
The story of Federation Square began in 1997 when an international design competition to create one of the great civic, cultural and commercial spaces on top of a railway yard which separated the city of Melbourne from it's river.
A jury unanimously selected two unknown London-based architects from 177 entries. And six months before it’s opening in October, 2002, the project was more than $200 million over budget.
Their radical design soon divided community opinion:
“It’s just dead ugly!”
“It’s an appalling waste of public money.”
“At least it’s a bit different.”
And my thoughts of Fed Square. Me, a New Zealander visiting Melbourne:
“I liked it! Strange, weird, interesting, lovely, very different. BUT certainly eye-catching! AND VERY EXPENSIVE!!”
Quoting it’s website:
“Conceived as a tribute to the first 100 years of Australian nationhood, Federation Square opened on 26 October 2002.
Standing in the heart of central Melbourne and linking the city centre with the Yarra River, Federation Square fuses art, architecture, hospitality and promenading into a distinct and striking public space. Visitors can stroll around Federation Square's expansive desert-toned plaza, which affords commanding views of Melbourne's riverside and cityscape, or enjoy food and wine at one of the 20 captivating restaurants, cafes and bars interspersed throughout the square.
Visitors can also take in a comprehensive collection of Australian art at the Ian Potter Centre: NGV Australia, or walk next door to see the state-of-the-art Australian Centre for the Moving Image.
Federation Square is also home to the Melbourne Visitor Centre - a one-stop shop for visitors to learn all there is to see and do in Melbourne and Victoria.
www.federationsquare.com.au
syd1946, daddo, peter1892, jmdaoudal, Propofol, Henryk_Bilor, cherryripe, macondo, Felip has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
syd1946
(17999) 2006-08-07 5:58
Hello Janice,
Very good idea for taking this shot.It has a great urban interesting.It amazing what buiidind made for their modern life.Well captured and a fine note!
Regards,
Thomas
daddo
(11647) 2006-08-07 6:38
Hi janice. I like your title and the way you conceived the composition. Close enough to feel its skin and far enough to see its shape. Nice work.Regards. Klaudio
ben4321
(9809) 2006-08-07 7:39
That's a very interesting looking building and I like your shot; its nice and bright with great colours and the composition is good.
In my opinion all this is missing is a bit of life; a passer by or someone sitting at one of the tables would have made this even better.
Cheers,
Ben
patric
(248) 2006-08-07 7:47
i disagree with the title of your picture.
ALL the lines i can see on this side of the building are even!
peter1892
(1681) 2006-08-07 13:41
Hi Janice - the detail here is very good, you've captured it well. Having some sky in the shot adds a bit of perspective & a touch of colour & contrast.
It's certainly a striking building, whether or not it will look good in the future is another question! Great notes, thanks.
jmdaoudal
(82) 2006-08-08 2:37
Ugly or not this is interesting when we look tighter to the effect of the faces and the real balance that exists in the surfaces.
the subject is interesting, as interesting tat the "quasimodo's face" :-))
Jean Michel
ktanska
(16743) 2006-08-08 6:41
Hi Janice,
Interesting design. Also the colour tones and reflections are funny. Whether it's ugly or not I can't decide just on this angle. Somehow I wish customer to that table to give more content.
Kari
Propofol
(1786) 2006-08-09 1:54
A helpful note, and a wonderful, clear photo. You chose your subject and your approach to it very well, to show off those bizarre angles we Melbournians recognise instantly.
Nice shot - congratulations!
Henryk_Bilor
(20375) 2006-08-11 5:13
Hello Janice
Impressing wall, indead. Very interesting shapes. I like the colours also.
Regards
cherryripe
(19237) 2006-08-21 4:42
Hi Janice
This building is not easy too photograph but I think you've succeeded as the colours and textures are excellent. The wires are in harmony with the shapes on the building and the blue sky with those lovely wispy clouds really sets it off well. I may just have framed it a tinge large to get the whole of the letter on the right.
Regards
Nikki
macondo
(13345) 2006-08-25 9:42
Ah, so you've been to Melbourne recently! Recogised this immediately. I'm one of those who hates it, especially the so-called windswept 'square' which is anything but. This is not to say you haven't made a really good, nicely contrasting shot out of it. You brought out the detail and texture of the wall really well. I wish there was someone sitting at one of those tables, but you can't have everything. The overhead cables in this actually lend interest, although you probably noticed that in general overhead wires are the curse of photographers in Melbourne. Hope you enjoyed your stay. I'll have a look to see if you've uploaded any more.
Regards,
Andrew
Felip
(3905) 2008-08-17 11:20
Interesting architecture design, that looks quite attractive, as equally interesting is the detail of the wires attached to the building. Tha POV and the angle chosen to take the pict are probably the best ones, and for me, they help to enhance the attractiveness of the building.
Good eye Janice.
Kind regards
Felip
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Janice Dunn (Janice)
(4386) - Genre: Places
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2006-07-31
- Categories: Daily Life, Architecture, Artwork
- Camera: Canon EOS 300D, Tamron AF28-300 XR
- Exposure: f/13.0, 1/400 seconds
- More Photo Info: view
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Travelogue: Melboure, Australia
- Date Submitted: 2006-08-07 5:41
Discussions
- To Propofol: Fed Square (1)
by Janice, last updated 08-09 07:34 - To jmdaoudal: Quasimodo (1)
by Janice, last updated 08-08 05:38








