Dramatic tree

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• ALIRIZA (13486)
• [2007-02-05 3:56]

Merhaba Sayın Hocam,
Dağlar, karanlık gökyüzünün arasından sızan ışık ve ışık almış dallarla harika bir kontrast. Gerçekten dramatik bir atmosfer. Ellerinize sağlık...
Selam ve saygılarımla...
Ali Rıza

•  
• Tezic (14228)
• [2007-02-05 4:02]

Merhaba İzzet Bey,
Sizin arada bir, böyle 15 sene ve/veya daha öncesi arşivinizden fotoğraflarınızı paylaşmanız bizler için emin olun çok değerli... Bunları görmek de büyük şans ve deneyim bizler için...
Sevgiler-Coşkun

•  
• barrufeto_77 (19578)
• [2007-02-05 4:08]

Merhaba Izzet.

A dramatic view! Nice composition with the tree as an introduction.

Well done!

Rgs, Oscar

•  
• rookie (149)
• [2007-02-05 4:12]

This is a lovely picture of natural art. I used to find trees without leaves plain and ugly. Now, (maybe because I am now older) I find them graceful in their simplicity. This is a nice juxtaposition of white on black. The cloud formations finished the feeling. Your POV is nice, although I probably would have cropped the bit of the next tree from the shot.

•  
• suhan (3516)
• [2007-02-05 4:36]

Harika ışık oyunları... Estetik dozu oldukça yüksek bir kare, dramatik etkisi de öyle.
(haddimize değil ama fotoğrafın solundaki -sanırız devamlılık arzetsin diye var olan- ağaç dalları olmasaydı nasıl olurdu?)
Teşekkürler, tebrikler
merve-süleyman

•  
• Dpbours (7048)
• [2007-02-05 4:49]

Very nice picture.
I like the balance with the mountain in the back. Almost seems like the tree has followed the shape of the mountain over the years, the shape of the first rays of sunlight in the morning...

Dennis

•  
• salvator (15454)
• [2007-02-05 5:09]

Hello Izzet Bey,
So interesting the leafless tree, the black hills and the grey clouds. The pov, the composition as well as the colors, are superb. The use of light the eye is different in every photo you share with us. Best personal regards. Salvator.

•  
• berek (22191)
• [2007-02-05 5:34]

Merhaba Izzet bey,
gerçekten dramatik. dalların üzerindeki ışık ve tabiki arka plana uyum muhteşem. elelrinize sağlık. saygılarımla.
Burak

•  
• mursaloglu (3609)
• [2007-02-05 6:31]

İzzet bey
Bu fotoğrafınızı çok kez gördüm ve sizi bana tanıtan fotoğraflarınızdan biri. Ellerinize sağlık.
Is one the best picture you've made. The light on the tree against dark mountain give a superb sense of contrast that makes the picture the stunning one. Best regards. ihsan

•  
• recepyuksel (17406)
• [2007-02-05 8:13]

Anlık değişimi şahane değerlendirmişsiniz, ışık da üstadını biliyor..
Saygılar..

•  
• coco (22971)
• [2007-02-05 11:17]

Merhaba Izzet.

You're right. Dramatic tree. And is this composition what enhances this dramatism.

Well done.

•  
• nwoehnl (60118)
• [2007-02-05 14:21]

Yes, it has a dramatic feel, Izzet. Compositionally it is rather simple, but the eerie lighting causes the barren tree silhouette to make an effectful appearance in front of the hills. Nice and moody, with an artistic touch.

•  
• SamB (1944)
• [2007-02-05 22:35]

Hello, Izzet--
Great piece, you used the lighting to great effect, and the way the shape of the tree is echoed in the silhouette of the mountain is great. My only criticisms are that the branches creeping in from the left are a little bit distracting and it sees a little noisy... oversharpened, maybe.
Thanks!
sam

•  
• a6parmak (28)
• [2007-02-06 2:34]

Merhaba İzzet Bey,bir sorum var ltf.Bu fotoğrafları çekmeden önce görüyormusunuz lütfen?Mükemmel olmuş.Elinize sağlık.

•  
• stiginthedump (1823)
• [2007-02-06 4:06]

I like this one a lot as well Izzet, but like SamB I have a small problem with the branches on the left of the other tree entering the frame. Also the nosie is a little too much for my liking in the clouds.....and theres the over sharpening la la la, but the silhouetted mountains are very nice!

•  
• persis (116)
• [2007-02-15 13:58]

Nice shot!

I love the tree, it seems to be apart from the photo

I love it!