Photographer’s Note
Any tour of the Turkish culture, whether it is my small tour of The Turkish Society of Rochester, New York (where I took this photo), or of the mainland of Turkey, would be incomplete without a reference to the “George Washington” of modern Turkey, Mustafa Kemal or Ataturk (the foremost Turk). Ataturk was a giant among the great statesman and reformers of all time. Ataturk participated in the Young Turk Revolt of 1908 (the archaic and corrupt Ottoman Empire was in dire need of major reforms) and later distinguished himself as a military leader in the Dardanelles and in Syria. His Nationalist Party came to power after WWI, much to the distrust of the former WWI allies, especially France and Great Britain, who had ulterior motives for their interests in the region (a continuation of self-interest and Imperialism). Ataturk had a huge job on his hands. He wanted to modernize and secularize the remnants of the old Ottoman Empire and to fight off the interference of foreign powers at the same time. Through some brief regional skirmishes and mostly through his diplomatic genius, he divided the bickering Allies (the former enemies of Germany and the Ottoman Empire during WWI) and led his country into the modern world. I think that his greatest achievement was to provide for a separation of church and state, much like that which was accomplished by the founding Fathers of the United States Constitution. Ataturk was a devout Muslim, but he didn’t want a modern day theocracy. Ataturk was a complex and controversial man in a complex part of the world with ancient roots and his legacy is a much revered one in Turkey today.
My late mother-in-law, a very seasoned world traveler, visited Turkey in the early 1990s and it was her favorite trip that she ever had. She was so fascinated with her tour that she told my mother about it and my mother went to Turkey a few years later. What impressed my mother the most about her tour of Turkey was Ataturk. She visited Gallipoli, the site of Winston Churchill’s disastrous campaign to attack the “soft underbelly” of Europe in WWI (Churchill was First Lord of the British Admiralty at the time). The ANZAC troops (Australian and New Zealand) had to bear the brunt of this bloody campaign for the British army. Hundreds of thousands of Turks and ANZACs lost their lives in the brutal and bloody battles that raged here.
In 1934 Ataturk gave a very moving speech of reconciliation at the ANZAC cemetery at Gallipoli. This is his speech. “Those heroes who shed their blood and lost their lives, you are now lying in the soil of a friendly country, therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side. Here in this country of ours, you the mothers who sent their sons from far away countries, wipe away your tears. Your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land, they have become our sons as well.”
Critiques | Translate
mesutilgim
(36317) 2008-02-17 12:40
Hi dear Stan, my dear friend !
What a great surprise again ! Very nice capture with perfect pov and compo. Great info's. Good light management. An entry which helps to many TE members to get some idea abot this great person.
Many many thanks and
Best regards
MESUT ILGIM
gunbud
(27559) 2008-02-17 12:53
Hi Stan,
Wonderful light management bring a lovely array of complimentary and contrasting colors to the foreground and excellent depth and detail the gold and yellow background. The white poster of the Turkish hero really stands out in this very detailed and sharp image. Wonderful note with a very warm conciliatory message.
Regards, Tom
delic
(6735) 2008-02-17 13:01
Hello Stan,
Indeed, Ataturk's greatest revolution was to establish secularism in Turkey. A lot of other reforms were built on that principle. Given the state of affairs in many Muslim countries and the rise of religious fundamentalism everywhere, including the States, we appreciate his vision even more. Great note that summarizes some of the unique qualities of this great man. Photograph is excellent despite the poor light. That little Nikon has done an outstanding job with flash and colors. Best wishes,
Hakan
pandoraTE
(2311) 2008-02-17 13:19
Thank you very much Stan. You understand Atatürk better than some people living in our country. He was realy one of the greatest persons in the world.
Regards
zmey
(7242) 2008-02-17 20:56
hello there stan
an interesting capture and share, indeed. ataturk in rochester, new york. now i know where to go for some photos of turkish people in the US a turkish friend asked me to make ;) very insightful your note to accompany this foto too. i enjoyed reading it. as to separation of state and "church", in islam it still remains to be seen how well it will work. if one studies islam deeper one comes to realize that the state (the law) and religion is pretty much woven together; full secularism (in the western sense of the word) being a very contradictory proposition for an islamic country.
cheers and thanks for sharing friend
kristaps
fulvio52
(8314) 2008-02-18 6:56
Hi, Stan.
Admittedly not my usual can of beer in terms of subject and composition, nevertheless : I more than appreciate your effort.
A tip of the hat to the photographer, and to that little killer Nikon.
Your light management is flawless! Each and every object in the picture (lots of them) is perfectly exposed, all the way to the dark & far background. And, of course, I appreciate your excellent note on Ataturk.
This is a great overall job, thanks for sharing.
Have a great day, see ya soon.
Ciao,
Fulvio.
meltemi
(9746) 2008-02-18 7:21
Hello Stan,
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk is, undoubtedly, one of the great personalities of the 20th century in the world as a statesman, politician and as the head of the state.
Sixty years after his death the Turkish people still tread in his steps. This way is so right that, it is possible to turn neither to the right, nor to the left. It shows Mustafa Kemal Ataturk's genius, wisdom and the result of his services before his people.
Thanks for you great moving note and for the flawless image, it's a very nice way to celebrate this great man.
Kind Regards.
Stella
Photo65Net
(43084) 2008-02-18 8:48
Stan,
A nice catch, with very informative note.
The picture itself is very nice, wouldn't have guess it was from NY !
Regards,
JB.
plimrn
(19558) 2008-02-18 18:30
Hi Stan,
As Tom notes, the contrasst between the pen & ink poster and the detailed BG is very effective. Once again you teach me about the world; your excellent note was a wonderful introduction to this great statesman. Ataturk's speech moved me to tears. Like Delic, I fear the increasing encroachment of religion in politics.
HLJ, Pat
sevy
(12945) 2008-02-19 0:43
Hello Stan,
As usual a very intersting note showing the complexity of Ataturk and of the today Turkey. It is well completed your photo and explains why the portrait is put in evidence even in far from Turkey.
The subjects linked to Turkey are topical questions in Europe as Turkey wants to join the European community and people are a little afraid it is a muslim country instead the european are mainly christian.
I am very curious to see how it will go on.
Yves.
Greg1949
(8507) 2008-02-22 5:43
Stan, I almost passed on this one but the note makes it a fantastic capture. Great work, this is exactly what TE is about I think.
Greg
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Stan Obert (scobert)
(5333) - Genre: People
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2007-06-16
- Categories: Event
- Camera: Nikon Coolpix P5000
- Exposure: f/4.5, 1/20 seconds
- Details: (Fill) Flash: Yes
- Photo Version: Original Version
- Date Submitted: 2008-02-17 12:29








