Portland Maine - Lighthouse

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• trinko (2928)
• [2006-12-28 17:35]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

nice composition but too dark. take a look at my workshop for an alternative view of this photo.

•  
• borka (222)
• [2006-12-28 17:41]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

Hi Mark, I also like your composition a lot, and I also made a workshop -
I would disagree with Tom that it is too dark, in my opinion it is mostly the contrast/saturation/noise issue. I also made a workshop, hopefully you like my version as well.
Regards,

Boris

•  
• cobbydale (1738)
• [2006-12-28 18:26]

This is a pretty good shot Mark, nice composition. It just needed the contrast and levels adjusting a bit as per Boris's excellent workshop.

Some notes would help though.
TFS. Leon.

•  
• asajernigan (9402)
• [2006-12-28 22:14]

Mark,
I like your composition here very much. Without the adjustments the photo has a very different mood than after it has been altered. I really like the original version and Boris' version, both have their merits.
Thanks for a great photo of the wonderful lighthouse.
Asa

•  
• Didi (30442)
• [2007-01-06 12:10]

Hello Mark
No your composition is not so dark.
It's ok with my flat screen, but it's not sufficient sharp.
The best WS is Boris one.
Cheers.

•  
• AROBN54 (8217)
• [2007-01-27 20:43]

I am inclined to agree with DIDI. I don't think it's too dark for the place and the mood, but some sharpening would make it much better. The composition is excellnt.