Minnesota Winter Home

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• osado (134)
• [2003-07-22 9:18]

nice panorama! I like the wheel on the left too, but maybe the house is too bright as in too much colourful.
Anyhow, a very nice shot!

•  
• PiotrS (433)
• [2003-07-22 10:09]

A superb panorama shot. I had a wintry forest picture ready to post, but after seeing yours, I don't think I'll bother!

I would love to see this full size on a wall, because I don't think a version this size does it justice. There is just too much detail here to take in all in. I think for the purposes of TE, a picture of the left hand side with the wheel and house would have made a superb posting in itself.

Great light and the picture looks sharp, I am a sucker for wintry scenes anyway. As for composition, the house provides an interesting object to focus on, although in this version it is perhaps too small to appreciate. The colour stands out well in the mostly B&W scene. Overall a beautiful photo. Send me the poster!

•  
• htremblay (1618)
• [2003-07-22 12:14]

Bonne composition,très belle photo. Bravo.
Good composition, very beautiful photo. Bravo.

•  
• PeskyPolecat (0)
• [2003-07-22 12:30]

Nice panoramic view, not sure if I would have included just a little bit of the snow at the base in the centre section.

•  
• ninadev (5074)
• [2003-07-22 17:41]

Panorama assembler hey! That gives a very good result, I'm impressed. I agree with Piotr's comments but would had that at first sight there is only one thing that bothers me a bit it's the white tree right in the middle that goes from the bottom to the top of the photo, it looks a little as the joining point of 2 photos. Doesn't show tehcnically but gives this impression. Great winter scene indeed and very peaceful feeling.

•  
• Mike (693)
• [2003-07-22 18:08]

Yes, this is great, panorama shots can never be shown in their true glory on the website, purely because of the dimension limits, I bet this is one fantastic picture in real life.

•  
• ronners (234)
• [2003-07-22 21:50]

Very nice shot. I love forest shots and the snow makes it even better. One small comment on my personal preference - I like to be able to see the bottom of all the trees, so when I frame I make sure that there's some free space at the bottom of the shot.

Take a look at this one to see what I mean.

Ron.

•  
• thien (2090)
• [2003-07-22 22:47]

Lovely shot with amazing light. The cartwheel is just great.

•  
• Motrem (2392)
• [2003-07-23 5:56]

Doux souvenir de l'hiver. Cette photo est empreinte de réalisme tellement elle est bien composée. L'effet de panorama apporte un impact très fort. A very nice shot!

•  
• dominique (11369)
• [2003-07-23 18:22]

Pretty landscape of winter, it is well made.

•  
• arunak (117)
• [2003-07-23 23:44]

Though I hate the long cold winters (in Canada) this shot gives me a good feeling, makes me wanting to see winter soon. I love the picture.