Evening on the Lake

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• cgrindahl (6103)
• [2004-07-29 1:35]
• [2] [+]

Boy, does this remind me of my childhood, much of which was spent in Upper Midwest lakes very much like this one. The panorama is breathtaking, despite how ordinary the scene it. This is just a lake, some boats, trees lining the shore and flat land as far as the eye can see. I imagine it was pleasantly warm on June 25.

The colors and details are rendered very nicely. You chose a gorgeous day with a spectacular sky for your photographic adventure. I notice a few artifacts at a what I imagine are intersections of individual images. Frankly, I'm amazed there is software that can do a credible job of this at all. And I imagine working with anomalies that arise is a very time consuming task. Despite those unlikely bends and angles, this is a breathtaking panorama. Thanks Paul.

•  
• Liora (1857)
• [2004-07-29 1:42]

A magnificent panorama Paul! tranquility as far as the eyes can see... Wonderful shades of blue.

•  
• papagolf21 (49857)
• [2004-07-29 3:31]

Félicitations Paul ! Un splendide panoramique, on a l'impression d'être sur place. Les couleurs sont parfaites et les ajustements sont invisibles.
Très belle composition.
7 images pour composer le panorama : c'est un exploit.
Very well done Paul.
Congratulations Paul! A panoramic magnificent, we have the impression to be spot. Colours are perfected and the adaptations are invisible.
Very beautiful composition.
7 images to compose the panorama: it is an exploit.
Very well done Paul.

•  
• summer89 (5414)
• [2004-07-29 5:11]

Hi Paul,

Great panoramic photo, i like the sky and all that lines.

Well done

•  
• ma-tibou (4566)
• [2004-07-29 6:11]

Magnifique travail, 7 photos , c'est vraiment une composition formidable, pour une vue panoramique grandiose. Bravo Paul.

•  
• carper (56364)
• [2004-07-29 6:14]

Oeps I had forgot the click on the photo. First I though, no this is nothing, and then when I clicked. Wauw, great one Paul. Very god LP photo, good colours and depth in it great job you did

•  
• Galeota (10315)
• [2004-07-29 7:14]

Beautiful panoramic view with a very interesting note. Well seen and composed.

•  
• elihesamian (25843)
• [2004-07-29 7:58]

Lovely moment,great in large version,excellent pano,Dear Paul!
I like it.
***
Bye for 10 days!
I'm very tired,need to go a calm place ,maybe in north of Iran.
and thanks for all kindly words by you.
see you:)

•  
• jhm (70015)
• [2004-07-29 8:06]

A very great panoramic Paul, very well done, congratulations!

•  
• harold (2267)
• [2004-07-29 8:42]

Très belle réalisation Paul, un formidable travail effectué. Bravo.

•  
• Kenny10pin (19253)
• [2004-07-29 11:18]

very good work here, I like the composition and also the dark colours are interesting too, good work here

Well done

•  
• richtersl (3542)
• [2004-07-29 12:12]

This view with which you've presented us is really grand. It was well worth the wait to compose the panorama without the boaters and jet skiers. This photo makes me feel as though I am sitting on the dock.

•  
• jurgen (1865)
• [2004-07-29 13:39]
• [+]

You did this with a tripod? The camera was practicaly horizontal because just a slight curvature can be seen on the horizon, that means this is a very good and patient work. A very nice place well captured. I like the reflections, specially those of the red pier on the water. The sky is also well captured, with some clouds for it to look not empty.

•  
• umbrellaphotos (2842)
• [2004-07-29 14:24]

you captured it. I'm from Minnesota and my father lives on a lake that looks just like this one. It brings me back! Nice shot.

•  
• nwoehnl (60423)
• [2004-07-29 15:23]

A genuinely wonderful sight, Paul. A beautiful panorama in which one of the treats is that the piers all appear to be oriented towards a concentric point in the middle. Wonderful colors and light, great clouds to top this serene view, and good stitching work with seven (!) photos. Very good jobs, thanks for sharing and embarking on this effort.

•  
• kajenn (2285)
• [2004-07-29 19:21]
• [+]

Lovely lake shot, Paul, and a marvelous panorama work again. This is so beautiful and so peaceful and so... different! A large lake entirely spring fed and a hundred feet above the surrounding plains!! But most of all - the way the boats are kept "overnight" - elevated with a little roof! Why? It's like they can't tolerate water! I've never seen anything like it and it amuses me. This is certainly learning about the world... ;o) Your picture is great, well composed and an almost 180° delicate stitching work with no visible joints. Very well done!

•  
• cmartos (6086)
• [2004-07-30 20:16]

What a wonderful panoramic view, with so much sharpness and clarity. I like your composition very much, I almost feel I'm THERE, participating in the scenery. The sky wonderful, as the lighting, you choosed the appropriate moment to shot. Excellent stiching work, never obvious, not at shutter release nor at assembly time, even if a software is partially doing the job. Fine shot, luminous, colorful and splendid rendered. Congratulations Paul!

•  
• bertolucci (11590)
• [2004-08-01 15:11]

Hi Paul, I like this well executed pano very much! It provides us with a very sharp and colurfull view. The fact that all the recreants have left for supper makes this a very tranquile pic - the lake holding it's breath for activities to return. The sky looks fantastic and a special elements is formed by the tent-roofs above some boats. Great job!

•  
• c_kyr (1810)
• [2004-08-03 11:07]

Very nice panorama Paul.
Great stiching here.
The view of the lake is wonderful, as well as the reflection of the clouds on the water.
Thanks for sharing!

•      
• jhonny_blue (4938)
• [2004-08-04 10:04]

Fantastic panoramic shot Paul ! It´s very good. Beautiful colours and a wonderful composition.
Congratulations

•  
• Rinie_Hoff (9316)
• [2004-08-04 18:15]

Hi Paul, I had seen this come by in a time that I could'nt rate much, but it was stilll in my mind. This is really a great panaoram of a very tranquil place, The sky is so beautiful, and it breathes such a peacefulness, I really like it. Also the sdmall version is great!

•  
• Endy (1025)
• [2004-08-04 21:32]

Lovely panorama! The clarity of the shot is perfect. I like the contrast of the red pier with the blue lake and sky.

•  
• joseelias (361)
• [2004-08-05 8:26]

Perfectly stitched panorama! The view is great with very nice details and colors.

•  
• gaetantgp (1310)
• [2004-08-09 22:14]

Superb panoramic view Paul! The large version is amazing, the sky is fantastic and the reflection in the lake is very sharp, we realy have the impression to be present at the marina with you. Thanks for sharing...Gaétan

•  
• Zanni (5859)
• [2004-08-27 2:40]

A great job, here Paul. The depth is very good and colours wonderful. The two gangways in foreground lead my eyes in a beautiful expanse of water. The human absence adds the sensation of a peaceful place.

•  
• ChrisJ (57444)
• [2004-09-30 5:31]

Great panoramic shot. Well done!