Noisy Peace

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• amstel (2103)
• [2005-12-02 15:50]

Nice shot, good composition. Black & white gives it a melancholic atmosphere. Where are the ships?:-)
Cheers Hamdam!

•  
• Amirsun (2088)
• [2005-12-02 17:12]

Hi Hamdam!
Very nice shot with great composition. Very good use of lines, diagonaly and verticaly. And vey good to put the boy in the golden spot.
Tanks fo rposting
Regards
Amir

•  
• papagolf21 (48531)
• [2005-12-02 17:43]

Bonsoir Hamdam,
C'est souvent qu'il faut accepter de prendre le risque «de faire quelques vagues» pour trouver sa voie. Un bateau qui reste au port n'est jamais en danger mais il ne va nulle part.
Ce pêcheur me semble bien rêveur, peut-être son esprit est déjà sur un bateau qui vogue sur des mers lointaines.
Le noir et blanc est parfait.
Amitiés.
Philippe

•  
• berek (23658)
• [2005-12-03 5:26]

Hi Hamdam ,

İ think very noise place. good B&W Taken. Clear picture. TFS. Have a nice weekend.
B.Erek

Sharpness : 6/10
Light : 6/10
Colour : -/-
Composition : 8/10
Idea :9/10
Note :9/10

•  
• feather (40651)
• [2005-12-03 8:44]

Good idea for the title; you have a contradiction there. I like the compositional device of including people in the scene who are looking at the same view we are. The opposing diagonals is also good compositionally. Converting to B&W is a good choice for an industrial scene.
Kath

•  
• jmdaoudal (18662)
• [2005-12-03 11:44]

I liked the last one for the quality of line and the pure quality, so this one is too.
Very good "mise en scene" for the harbour and even if the fisherman is a strong part, the perspective behing is great and very "clean".
I also like the use of BW here
Compliments
jean Michel

•  
• jhm (67812)
• [2005-12-03 12:22]

Hi Hamdam,
Maybe give black and white a extra atmosphere to the picture, I'm not a great fan of B/W, I find colour picture always most beautiful, the digonal and vertical lines its absolutely not bad.
Execellent composition.
Have a nice sunday.
John.

•  
• ishai (4074)
• [2005-12-03 17:34]

I love the lines here
The dominating cranes against the fishing rod

The transformation to B&W makes it peaceful

Nice presentation

ishai

•  
• BlaiseCendrars (0)
• [2005-12-04 9:16]

Looks like they are all fishing, even the cranes!

Great composition Hamdam!

Kheyli mamnoun

Chris

•  
• Galmeida (12559)
• [2005-12-05 10:58]

Hi Hamdam,
Excelent option with the B&W in this scenery from the bridge. Good use of lines, diagonal and geometric patterns. Fine enquadrement, light, contrast and sharpness. A daily life scene with a thinking fisherman very well captured and framed.

Congratulations and Best Regards.
Fernando

•  
• AiresSantos (25614)
• [2005-12-08 4:31]

Hi Hamdam, very nice black and white shot !
I like the diferent lines in this daily life composition. Very good sharpness and contrast.
Well done,
Aires dos Santos.

•  
• azadys (708)
• [2005-12-09 6:36]

HI Dear Hamdam.
nice shot. great choosen of B/W. but i think more cintrast makes the Photo more impressive.
of course still nice shot.

regards
azad

•  
• john_c (24616)
• [2005-12-09 11:09]

Hi Hamdam,
An interesting, well composed shot. I like the laconic attitude of the fisherman and the casuality of the scene amidst a busy industrial area. Great incongruity here, with industry on the far shore and a day fisherman just relaxing on the bridge. The B&W format also works well. Great capture, Hamdam.
John

•  
• elihesamian (25819)
• [2005-12-10 13:42]

hello Hamdam,
What a nice work in B&W !
I like the graphism aspects in this one with a perspective here,too,well worked and captured and composed,seems the boy is deep in a thinking and waiting for a fish to break his dream :)
Best to You
M

•  
• saamb (1002)
• [2005-12-11 0:30]

great shot, and nice "Black & White". see a good composition in photo.
thanks

•  
• golzarian (100)
• [2005-12-19 3:08]
• [+]

Hi,
Very nice work.
I like that crossed lines alot.
good in BW mode.
Regards,
MOhsen Golzarian

•  
• quantabeh (5163)
• [2005-12-25 2:43]

Hello Hamdam,
I like your composition, and the mood and atmosphere you show here. the choice of black white is actually pretty good for this.
cheers,
Behrang

•  
• rahul__rahul__ (2250)
• [2006-01-19 16:30]

Hi Hamdan,
nice shot, the b/w is effective and it is sharp, with good contrast. Nice note. Thanks for sharing!
Regards,
Rahul

•  
• bazal (7886)
• [2006-04-05 4:57]

Hi Hamdam.
Nice picture of this man quietly fishing in the harbour... Very good use of the b&w that give some nostalgic atmosphere to the shot.
Thanks for sharing.
Regards.