That obscure object of beauty!

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• abulafia (4473)
• [2007-04-08 7:15]

Hi Salar
This is a truly great B+W shot, the sky is wonderful dramatic, and the light is very good. I like the seagulls in the air and only wished that the wooden remains of the pier was a little better detailed.
A note would have been nice.
Regards
Harry

•  
• marmur82 (0)
• [2007-04-08 7:23]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Hello salar!
I like your PoV,but I think it'd be better if you point your lens more to the right.
check my WS

Regs.
mm.

•  
• charmante (1053)
• [2007-04-08 7:43]

Wow, reminds me of absurd places in absurd movies..
I like the way u've divided yr composition into 2/3 for sky & 1/3 for the sea. beautiful impression.Also like the contrasts & all the gray shades that u've obtained.
did u make it in the shot or got it in photoshop? anything u've done, u've done it great.
me also prefereed u've added a note.

•  
• Furachan (0)
• [2007-04-08 8:01]

Beuatiful, haunting shot, Salar, the wa the sky opens in front of our eyes, exploding in a way above these broken pontoons. Absolutely outstanding B/W tonal treatment to make it happen.
First rate,
Francis

•  
• skellywag (875)
• [2007-04-08 8:18]

Hi, a beautiful scene, enhanced by the B&W tones. it is romantic and desolate. Really nice composition, Regards Jean

•  
• paido (944)
• [2007-04-08 10:57]

Great shot salar!

The clouds, the birds, the tones... I like about everything in here.

•  
• falcon53 (336)
• [2007-04-08 12:07]

Very dramatic, but yet sombre picture. In addition to the flock of birds flying left to right, I like the perspective provided by the cloud formation.

•  
• jaywalker (9417)
• [2007-04-08 12:25]

Hi Salar, A wonderfully composed photo, the chose of B/W was perfect, the brilliant sky has picked out the flock of birds superbly well, great POV & a great photo, kind regards Wilson.

•  
• psychache (1825)
• [2007-04-09 5:47]

Hi,
Very nice B/W photograph. Composition and grey tones are beatiful. TFS

With my best regards

•  
• daddo (8035)
• [2007-11-08 22:52]

Salam Salar. Very creative PoV showing us the imposing sky. The flock of birds and the the ancient dilapidated pier add to the contemplative mood. An excellent creation. Regards. Klaudio.