Stella

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• limule (2145)
• [2006-10-14 16:29]
• [+]

hi, this wonderful picture really desserve a comment. It is a pity that you did not take any time for that. Anyway the picture is just perfect, strange , looking like a suburb area , not human at all, with in parallel a lot of tenderness between these 2 persons and their particular clothes. I like the fact their back is touching the glass of the bus station (something like that isn't it ?). Beautiful picture from a technical point of view, but also artistical dimension very far from traditional landscapes and portraits. Congratulations.

•  
• Lemy58 (201)
• [2006-10-14 16:31]

Belle image ou les tags sont en opposition avec la génération présentée. Les couleurs sont attrayantes tout en donnant l'apparence de ne pas vouloir brusquer les personnages.

•  
• russte (0)
• [2006-10-14 17:09]
• [+]

Welcome to TE (and a special welcome as I see you use a KM 5D ;-) ). This is a wonderful, wonderful image. I love how you've used the graffiti and the textured glass of the bus stop(?) to such creative effect. Perfectly framed and a spot on exposure too. The only thing I don't like is the very unnatural shape under the man's coat as he leans against the glass - almost as if he had a tamborine hidden there. Very odd. Anyway, I look forward to more of your work. Stephen

•  
• Traczewska (5030)
• [2006-10-14 17:45]
• [+]

There is a certain anegdote in your shot which I really like. Old pepole, young style of the frame.. surprising, impressive connection..
Welcome to TE. Best, Agnieszka

•  
• vapours (7461)
• [2006-10-14 23:55]

What a great first shot for TE, love the contrast between the dirty looking graffiti and the old grannies dressed in their sunday clothing with the effect of the frosted glass. My kind of shot. Well done Faros, hope to see more similar shots like this from you :)

•  
• Tristan-z (1025)
• [2006-10-15 3:35]

Bienvenue sur treakearth. Trés belle image pour commencer. Bravo.

•  
• P-S-I-G (20851)
• [2006-10-15 5:24]

Salut,
Très belle entrée en matière sur TE.
Un regard très original. Une photo fort bien composée avec cette juxtapositon des tags avec ces voyageurs âgés. Excellente scène urbaine, j'aime beaucoup.
Très bonne continuation.
Amicalement,
Fabrice

•  
• prospere (693)
• [2006-10-15 8:37]

Belle composition !
Originale et très bien cadrée.

Bonne continuation,

Ludovic

•  
• Mojgan (44)
• [2006-10-15 12:19]

A very interesting and also odd picture. This sense of vagueness has added to the charm of this photo. It would be much better if you have written something in the note section.
Mojgan

•  
• hickthom (326)
• [2006-10-15 15:16]

This is a great shot... Don't see many of those on this site.. Je dois dire que le contraste entre le moderne des graffiti et le motif floral de la robe est excellent.. Sans parler de l'effet glace de la vitre et la marque du veston presse contre celle ci..

•      
• scalerman (19706)
• [2006-10-15 15:50]

Faros, of your two posts thus far, this one is salient. Great compo and theme in your approach. regards, c

•  
• vinicio (19044)
• [2006-10-16 9:07]

Excellent fine and clever shot Phil, compliments, good idea and great result, I like it, well done.
Ciao
Vinicio

•  
• cobraphil8 (11066)
• [2006-10-16 10:58]

Bienvenu sur TE et quel beau début de galerie, celle-ci est vraiment belle avec cette opposition ou plutôt cette intégration d'une génération dans l'autre...
J'aime beaucoup.
Bravo
Philippe

•  
• dolin (15647)
• [2006-10-17 11:03]
• [+]

Hi Faros.
Excellent one, I like this view.
Strange, funny,...good idea.
The "peace......stella" give a good touch and the colors tones are really good..
Nice shot
Fred

•  
• davidkral (58)
• [2006-10-18 1:51]

Ahoj! This picture doesn't need any comment. Gently humour, I wanna be their grand son ...

•  
• tobourge (715)
• [2006-10-18 5:09]

Bonjour Faros,

Superbe! Quelle drôlerie ;-)

Bien vu!

Merci

Tony

•  
• danyy (49774)
• [2006-10-18 14:27]

Hello,
je profite de ce passage pour te souhaiter la bienvenue sur TE.
Une photo remplie d'originalité et bien dans l'esprit du site.
Regards.
Daniel.

•  
• Luko (13479)
• [2006-10-18 17:19]
• [+]

C'est superbe, Phil! j'adore l'effet "vitrail", le même qu'un temps de pluie, sur les couleurs saturées... assez marrant le contraste entre les petites fleurs de mémé et le stella taggé destroy.

peut être que simplement le "se" de droite est de trop, mais c'est du pinaillage...

•  
• greg (2837)
• [2006-10-20 12:20]

Yeah, that's really nice. At one end of life you press your nose against the window...

•  
• elBud (2183)
• [2006-10-20 15:47]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment] - [workshop] [compare] [+]

•  
• Framboisilla (5386)
• [2006-10-21 3:18]

Hello Phil,

Voici une idée originale qui me plaît bien... J'aime bien le côté caché derrière la vitre de ce petit couple. Les graffitis du premier plan contrastent avec l'image ! Bien vu et en plus c'est joliment coloré.

Stéphanie.

•  
• xavshot (45415)
• [2006-10-21 7:22]

Bonjour Phil,
je m'arrête aujourd'hui sur cette belle photo très originale. J'apprécie beaucoup l'idée de la comp et la réalisation qui est excellente. Très joli graphisme. Bravo
amicalement
Xavier

•  
• mdetay (3688)
• [2006-10-21 21:34]

Salut Phil,
Excellente composition.
Tres bien vu et cadré.
Super couleurs.
Excellent.
Bien amicalement.
Michel

•  
• GLEM (2784)
• [2006-10-22 8:28]

bonjour Faros,

Très surprenant comme image, quel coup d'oeil vous avez.
Les incriptions sur le noir, correspondent-elles aux noms des personnes assises sur les bancs ? :)

tfs

•  
• faubry (27199)
• [2006-10-22 18:31]

hello Faros, very funny and original photo! good ideé! bravo for this composition, like "vitrail"
thanks
francine

•  
• m_s_s (1616)
• [2006-10-22 19:25]

Wonderfull composition Faros.
how well you've captured this couple together with signs. what i like mostly in this photo is back of this guy - squeezed in a little bit to the glass. well done. thanks for sharing.
regards

•  
• rigoletto (19906)
• [2006-10-22 19:28]

Hello Faros,
Brilliant picture! At first I misunderstood, as I just thought that it was a blurry picture. After seeing the contact surfaces of the people's backs with the window, I was just amazed. I could not get your aim of including the "Stella" issue into the pic. However, the originality of the score deserves two (more than two) points.
Congrats,
Deniz

•  
• sebinho342 (17015)
• [2006-10-23 5:01]
• [+]

Salut Faros,
Ah ah c'est toi qui a fait celle la ! Ca tombe que j'ai l'opportunité de la critiquer car je l'avais déjà vu passer dans la gallerie et elle est vraiment excellente !!!
Elle ne laisse vraiment pas indifférent, elle interpelle, elle attrape le regard, peu commune a ça c'est sur, pleine d'originalité.
très visuelle, ah la la c'est pas drole de vieillir et d'attendre son bus ;)
Bravo, une très belle photo

•  
• snowfalken (1098)
• [2006-10-24 13:41]

Hi Faros,

This is a very original picture from you! Great POV! Very nice rendition of the textured glass. Congratulations!

Regards,
Eddie

•  
• semra (133)
• [2006-10-26 12:30]

very nice..

•  
• yesterday (9596)
• [2006-10-26 21:52]

SPLENDID composition, new and old meet ind this, great effekt vith the sharp front and the rustik glass, excellent color and contrast.

•  
• adores (11345)
• [2006-11-04 13:36]
• [+]

Hi there Faros!
I think this one is so great and original. The kind os photo we generally don't even think about taking.Colours are great and these words written at the back... it's great, really!
Regards, Anabela

•  
• marknunnerley (2760)
• [2006-11-08 12:39]
• [+]

Hi Faros,
I don't know about you but I never look at the marks awarded when I look at anyones photographs. But I have to say that this is the best. It's got that bit of mystery to it. Even the graffiti adds to it all. It's like they are having a really good gossip and have steamed the windows up. Very enjoyable Faros.
Regards,
Mark

•  
• baba_flies (4072)
• [2006-11-09 9:21]
• [+]

Dear Faros ... you have heard it many times as I can see, but it is a super cool photo. It shows so well how worlds can collide ... the old couple sitting there not understanding our world ... or maybe they do. We can only guess work. So well done, really. Barbara.

•  
• flory (4539)
• [2006-11-11 2:25]
• [+]

ciao Faros,
brilliant idea for this photo...i like the fact their back is touching the glass of the bus station..intersting effect;new and old meet in this picture..
have a nice weekend,
flory

•  
• voightlanderfan (0)
• [2006-12-04 10:39]

Exellent, very well seen and funny.
Bravo.

Steph.

•  
• Standa (1861)
• [2007-01-29 14:32]

Hi, static but pulsating photo. Beautiful idea. Congratulations.

•  
• king (2411)
• [2007-05-15 16:26]

Hello Phil
Really great picture!!!!
TFS.
Huub de K.

•  
• flashpoint (1887)
• [2007-07-16 10:32]

Hey Phil I am I the bearer of peace. ......... excellent release ciao Sergio

•  
• KKar (456)
• [2007-08-09 1:17]
• [+]

Phil apart for any technical stuff what i personally search in photografy is to feave some feeling. Not sentimental any kind of feeling. This picture is not justa representation of daily life. It can be "read" with various ways. The old people that turned their back to the rest of the world (or the world has turned their back to them. The everlasting love story. The inavoidability of time (the angle behind the foggy window gives the feeling that they are lost in the mist of time) . Finally the graffity that you picked as title . A decleration of devotion? Could be. Excelent work
thank you for sharing
Kostas (be back tomorow)

•  
• sotiris_k (660)
• [2007-08-15 6:25]

Hi Phil,
A talking picture... I like the contrast between the blairy old couple and the clear contemporary art (graffitti). The fact that makes this picture beatiful to my eyes is that both the two themes in this frame have elements that are outstanding. The old and the modern have their own special grace...

TFS
Sotiris

•  
• mikeo (7497)
• [2007-10-20 6:42]

Hi Phil,

what an amazing shot...it has so great climate...superb composition...
very good idea for pic!

Btw why no note? I am sure any short story would be great here;)

Greetings
Aga

•  
• fryz (1668)
• [2007-10-24 10:34]

extra celle-ci aussi ;)
l'opposition force tranquille (papi/mamie) et délinquance (tag)
a+ Phil
Vincent

•  
• designsoul (21302)
• [2008-01-05 21:12]
• [+]

Hello Phil,
I've been a bit absent but come back to TE now and then... and am so glad to find this shot of yours which I will put into my favs immediately... superb one, everything about it is, but especially the man's coat so close to the glass pane. That is the gem of it all... unbelieavable work, am green with envy!
Take care
sasa

•  
• grandklaus (423)
• [2008-01-15 9:00]

hello Phil
je viens de "feuilleter " ton portofolio et la dernière que je visionne (la première que tu as postée) me saisit
la "Stella " d'untramway nommé désire , maintenant vieille , attend tranquilement le bus en parlant de "peace " avec un monsieur de son age. C'est peut etre le flou de la vitre qui induit ce vagabondage rèveur dans le commentaire
bravo , belle image
JEFF

•  
• Tipuss (419)
• [2008-01-29 0:05]
• [+]

Super! C'est un sujet que j'aurais voulu entreprendre moi-même de manière systématique (transparence, abris bus) dans un proche avenir. Le commentaire est peut-être un peu trop "fort" : l'image me semble très gaie (la jolie robe à fleurs aplatie contre la vitre). Amitiés, Eva

•  
• meb (481)
• [2008-01-31 6:47]

Hi Phil,
this is a perfect shot, but the note... too sad !!!
Your are an artist.
Best regards
Marica

•  
• totoamoto (1306)
• [2008-02-24 0:58]

Salut Phil..
La photo se nomme Stella.. mais il y aussi le mot "peace"..
Comme si les 2 personnages faisaient la paix..:)
Bravo pour ce coup d'œil..
Cyril

•  
• tamatree (221)
• [2008-04-08 4:32]

GORGEOUS!!

•  
• isindir (158)
• [2008-06-07 13:50]
• [+]

I like figures on this photo, but these bright graphities kills the mood and take out attention from the main subject...