<< Previous Next >>

there were 9 classes in this 1 building


there were 9 classes in this 1 building
Photo Information
Copyright: Catherine M D (noborders) Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1440 W: 59 N: 2872] (11654)
Genre: People
Medium: Color
Date Taken: 2006
Categories: Daily Life
Exposure: f/2.8, 1/10 seconds
Photo Version: Original Version
Theme(s): ~ Haiti, everyday life, Classrooms worldwide, Children of the World [view contributor(s)]
Date Submitted: 2007-03-24 13:26
Viewed: 2109
Points: 10
[Note Guidelines] Photographer's Note
(see also : in the far and to the right, same building, the youngest children)
In one of the schools visited in the commune of Paillant (above Miragoane), there were 9 teachers in a large one-room building, busy with 260 children (not all present though), all in primary school although some of them were obviously more than 12 years old.

As this school seemed located in the middle of nowhere, I asked how many of the pupils had to walk for more than one hour one way to reach their school, and about a third of the children raised their hands.

Having visited plenty of primary schools in Indian countryside since some 20 years, I was struck by some differences : yes, there too the children are wearing uniforms, but they are generally sitting on the floor (and no one is complaining about this), and there, the lack of buildings is dealt in another way : instead of putting all the classes under one roof, the classes are spread out inside the courtyard, in the open, under trees with the black board hanging from branches (I must admit that I rarely visit India during the monsoon)...

About the school manuals and books, in Haiti they are generally imported from other French speaking islands in the Carribbean ; whereas in India, they are printed locally (of course, it is necessary as there are so many different languages and types of writing in India).

The school books are bought by charities (unfortunately not enough for the number of students) and remain the property of the school ; at the end of the year, the students give them back to the master who will lend them to the following students. I must admit that I did not enquire about this in India, but it seemed that school books, which seemed rare and precious, were not handled by children individually and always remained in the school compound.

I also asked myself another question : sponsoring a project in Haiti or in India costs us in the west the same price, 30 euros each month (via Aide et Action, Paris); but the cost of living is very different, much more expensive in Haiti, so when I try to help a project there, the amount that I pay each year is much more effective in India than it is in Haiti, unfortunately...

So much needs to be done there, that it looks a little overwhelming. But these schools have been established by the local community and Aide et Action is only helping for some time each school, in this instance, providing those wooden benches and some school material.


Some of the parents have so little cash that they cannot even pay for the *annual* school fees, only 5 or 6 dollars ; the dedicated teachers are often paid only with farm crops or chickens (or other farm animals).

All children have to wear a uniform ; they are not allowed into the classroom if they don't have a pair of shoes (exceptions are made in some schools for the new comers). The little girls are combed with great care...

KrL, maloutim, riclopes has marked this note useful
Only registered TrekEarth members may rate photo notes.
Add Critique [Critiquing Guidelines] 
Only registered TrekEarth members may write critiques.
Discussions
ThreadThread Starter Messages Updated
To maloutim: éducation des filles et des plus pauvres en Hanoborders 2 04-12 06:46
You must be logged in to start a discussion.

Critiques [Translate]

  • Great 
  • KrL Gold Star Critiquer [C: 51 W: 1 N: 4] (58)
  • [2007-03-28 6:09]

Bonjour Catherine,
Ta note nous explique bien le contexte.
C'est incroyable d'avoir autant d'enfants regroupés dans un seul endroit sans qu'ils soient plus isolés les uns des autres

Karèle

Encore une photo intéressante et instructive sur l'Ecole en Haïti. Malgré l'extème misère du pays, c'est agréable de voir l'effort accompli pour venir à l'école habillé de façon décente.
Mais cela veut-il dire que les plus pauvres n'ont pas accès à l'école?
D'autre part, je note une majorité de garçons: ceci voudrait dire que les parents misent d'abord sur l'éducation de leurs fils, ce qui est bien dommage.
Merci du partage.
Marie Louise.

Yo Catherine,

it's great how you have a sea of these yellow shirts and interested eyes. It's a nice angel you've taken to allow the frame be really open.

Nice work.

Bonsoir Catherine
Il y a peu de photos d'Haiti sur TE d'où l'intérret de tes images. Ici tout semble bien en ordre. L'image est tes belle malgré un petit défaut de nettété dû à l'obscurité.
Amicalement
Bertrand

Again, it's really interesting the way you absorb the culture of the places you visit. It sure would be nice to have someone like you around me, while travelling, because I'm too shy to get into visits like these. This is really packed up, but I guess that's a good thing to - so many children having education, instead of working in the fields. 9 classes in the same place - what a mess it must be...but I imagine that the behaviour must be good and not terrible like in the places around my place (I actually gave up teaching because I couldn't manage well the bad behaviour...)
Ricardo

Calibration Check
















0123456789ABCDEF