Photographer’s Note
What would you do differently? huh ... what?
they didn't stop the bombs falling on my Afghanistan...
...neither would you!
what would you do differently...when my son was dying...they threw food from helicopters...when I needed hope and help...they gave me dollars...and what would you do?
can you give me my life back?
can you bring my son back?
the freedom that you keep so dear for yourself...
...would you give me that freedom...
or would you free me up once and for all....
drop bombs at me...so that my chilren lose their limbs...their hand, legs...so my children loose their hope...
will you do that for me?
...will you?
-------------------------------------------------------
I was humbled by this woman...sitting on a footpath in the outskirts of Rawalpindi...
Critiques | Translate
LeeLoo
(4984) 2008-12-10 3:38
Dear Kamran Channa!
Very interesting old woman.
Good point of view.
Original portrait.
Great effect.
Good luck!
TFS!
imtiyaz
(997) 2008-12-10 3:45
Excellent POV,
the B&W works well here,
One point the white vehicle in the background distracting the image,
Except that every thing is really amazing here.
Congrats,
Imtiyaz Basha M S
ninaL
(19450) 2008-12-10 4:03
Hi, Kamran.
Strong and impressive.
Very speaking photograph.
Best regards. Grazyna.
bantonbuju
(48514) 2008-12-10 4:05
truly serious and touching portrait...
i'm impressed by the seriousness of what i see here...
great work,
best wishes, jerzy
adamchewts01
(838) 2008-12-10 4:12
I don't know what help can I provide but surely I would not do any dumb things to intentionally or unintentionally hurt someone to this stage.
I pray to God for his forgiveness and bless this people with mercy and provide them hope and ease their suffering.
Adam
Morac
(20227) 2008-12-10 4:27
Hello Kamran
"All men are born free and equal ..."
Today is the 60th anniversary of "The Universal Declaration of Human Rights".
Your photo and your text are welcome to remind us that there is still much work ...
Regards
Marc
daddo
(11279) 2008-12-10 4:41
Salam Kamran. The tragic face of the Afghanistan. Where does the blame lie? When did it all begin? With the concept of nationhood? How to hold disparate peoples within artificially imposed borders? Powerful shot- that a human being should be reduced to this! B&W seems to be your forte.Regards. Klaudio.
BennyV
(4614) 2008-12-10 5:45
A very, very powerful post in image and words, Kamran. Humbling is the word, humbled...
Benny
andywo
(2819) 2008-12-10 6:34
Hi Kamran
Interesting shot, good portrait of this old women, nice B&W version and very good note! Excellent done.
Congratulations!!!
Andrzej
liviu
(600) 2008-12-10 6:51
I have no critique for your photo, I have no critique for the title, I have no critique for the note... all are good and sad...
liviu
pisces
(770) 2008-12-10 7:00
Hi Kamran!
Striking B/W portrait. Love the expression on the old woman's face! Great POV and sharpness!
TFS
Maria
holmertz
(9528) 2008-12-10 7:19
Hello Kamran,
A rather shocking picture that could leave nobody indifferent. It was interesting to compare it to the one in colour. I find this much stronger, partly because b&w allows us to concentrate more on the subject, partly because we see more of her haunted face.
TE needs this kind of pictures much more than all those lovely views of beautiful scenery, IMHO.
Best wishes,
Gert
tomescuc
(2837) 2008-12-10 12:46
Hello Kamran,
The image is simply superb, the subject matter tragic. One thing that strikes me in the image is how you juxtaposed this miserable and sad sitting woman with the background behind - moving past, almost oblivious to her plight. Excellent documentary work.
My compliments,
Cristian
alftrek
(2771) 2008-12-10 18:52
Hello Kamran,
I like your photo and the rather moving note, both convey the immensity of suffering and poverty of this old woman. Her expression tells it all and it is superbly captured. The expression is so touching that I wonder whether I should treat this outstanding photographic work as a piece of art for my leisure viewing and comments. I believe you have done well to share the ugly side of the world which is not always colourful and pleasant.
I think the natural lighting was not with you, so I did a quick PP to lighten up her face. Do let me know what you think, Kamran.
Thanks for sharing something so meaningful.
Regards
Alfred
aadilj
(17950) 2008-12-10 21:49
Assalamwalaikum Kamran and Bakrid Mubarak, I was away to my hometown and just returned. Wow this is well captured indeed. very sad and very telling, the more I look for the difference between our countries, the more similarities I find!
SteveH
(3885) 2008-12-11 0:12
Hi Kamran, What to say, the note together with the image make something very powerful. On the image I think I would have preferred it without the van on the LHS, perhaps with her more to the left. Being very picky - there seem to be some smudges in the sky - PP artifacts, perhaps? But hats off to you for getting down and making this image and sharing those thoughts. cheers, Steve
jorgi
(3798) 2008-12-12 1:35
Hi Kamran,
I will be really short this time, because you already said it all and the photo speaks for itself in best possible way.
My humble compliments,
Jeri
Atousa
(3434) 2008-12-12 22:18
Salam Kamran,
This is so sad yet true unfortunately ! .. B n W works well here , for it shows a hurting truth ..the BG says indirectly that how much indifferent sometimes we are toward what is really going on around us!..TFS
Regards, A
atif_ge
(660) 2008-12-13 4:14
Dear Kamran sb,
You have exposed a very painful reality in your photograph. Great work man, Thanks for sharing. ATif
ikas
(611) 2008-12-14 3:11
kamran ji,
u did excellent job, its really hard to anticipate good subject and then to capture it
take care n bye
irfan
isabela_sor
(42022) 2008-12-14 4:19 [Comment]
macondo
(13071) 2008-12-16 4:17
Hi Kamran.
Amazing shot; I'm glad I caught up with it. I also looked at the WS. I think it would have worked just as well if the background had been darkened - the converse of what you have here. Anyway, it's the close-up wide angle view of this pathetic and tragic figure which makes the photo so stunning. The incredibly bitter look on her gnarled face, and the way she has shrunk herself down to occupy the absolute minimum space. I don't find the van a distraction as it reminds us that the banalities of life go on regardless of the human tragedy played out silently on the footpath. I don't know if I'd be bold enough to take a shot like this. Great work.
Regards,
Andrew
ls7902
(6134) 2009-01-13 0:41
Hello Kamran,
Really good POV & proximity to give a strong & powerful presence. Can almost hear her sadness & lamentation. Regards. Latiff.
delpeoples
(5810) 2009-01-20 1:51
Oh God, what a fantastic - yet tragic - shot. I feel like crying. Brilliant work Kamran. Kind regards, Lisa
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Kamran Channa (kschanna)
(2634) - Genre: Places
- Medium: Color
- Date Taken: 2008-01-04
- Categories: Daily Life
- Camera: Fujifilm FinePix S6500fd, Rowa 58mm MC UV
- Exposure: f/7.1, 1/280 seconds
- Photo Version: Original Version, Workshop
- Theme(s): Images with touching notes [view contributor(s)]
- Date Submitted: 2008-12-10 3:34
Discussions
- To Morac: some are more (1)
by kschanna, last updated 12-11 18:18 - To aadilj: Kher Mubarak (1)
by kschanna, last updated 12-11 12:20 - To SteveH: the van (1)
by kschanna, last updated 12-11 12:18








