ANOTHER WORLD-II

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• bodobose (242)
• [2007-10-16 8:19]

Partha'da...from a class photographer, you are becoming a class apart photographer and I am happy to see you growing day by day. world class photography by any standards. hat's off my friend, keep the good work going

•  
• ninaL (15327)
• [2007-10-16 8:19]

Hi, Partha.
Impressive scene with these clouds and with your strong PP.
Very good contrasts, I like it.
Best regards. Grazyna.

•  
• Polonaise (15278)
• [2007-10-16 8:22]

Your hopes came true...
I love it.
It's one of this old, traditional schools of decent photography...
show your objecy as attractive as possible, even if you have to call upon the help from heavens...(:-)))

In this case...The heavens were listening.
This cloudy backgrouns is one heck of a support for your charming beauty.

Roll up with passion, Partha

george

•  
• anes_lc (13639)
• [2007-10-16 8:22]

perfect picture Partha
great quality ..the best i must say
great conversion in b&w
regards,anes

•  
• Paolo (39619)
• [2007-10-16 8:26]

Hi Partha, wonderful one, with a fantastic old style mood, thanks, to the b/w and the strong contrast.
excellent exposure too and perfect quality.
great shot.
thansk, ciao

•  
• dareco (8528)
• [2007-10-16 8:27]

A beautiful composition!! Love the b&w. Great pov and detail. TFS

•  
• carlab (1890)
• [2007-10-16 8:42]

Hi Partha, your shots of India are fantastic!
tfs
Carla

•  
• yazdi (409)
• [2007-10-16 8:42]

Hello Partha;
Its very beautiful image with great choice of selecting it in B/W and great sharpness.
Regards!
Jamal

•  
• osh (339)
• [2007-10-16 8:47]

very impressive photo and very powerful background. great!

•  
• GG_Poland (684)
• [2007-10-16 8:49]

hi Partha

excellent one. the composition and the conversion are great. beautiful contrast and light.

good work
greetings
Grzegorz

•  
• rishabh6296 (692)
• [2007-10-16 9:04]

Excellent shot Partha,it looks like a painting.
Rishabh

•  
• sidstakes (738)
• [2007-10-16 9:08]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Hello Partha....this is yet another wonderful shot of Birbhum from you. I have been very impressed with your work from Birbhum, some of the shots are just terrific!
I tried a workshop for a different toning. Very slight.

•  
• MarcT (12099)
• [2007-10-16 9:16]

Hi Partha,
like everybody else I share the same feelings.
Great B&W picture, excellent contrasts.
Regards
Marc

•  
• dhurjati (3258)
• [2007-10-16 9:21]

Hi Partha,
I was a great fan of your previous "Another World" shot, and this is no exception.It's a dream shot for anyone.How you composed it, is really wonderful to see and to learn from it.The olden days mood is what most appealing here.Wonderful work.
Greetings,
Dhurjati

•  
• faubry (27225)
• [2007-10-16 9:28]

wonderful image, like a old picture, i like quiete atmospher, superb, bravo
francine

•  
• photographer123 (4143)
• [2007-10-16 9:44]
• [+]

hi partha..
Impressive work..very good use of clouds..little over sharped..do u use any filter?well done...subir

•  
• tehanu_f (5353)
• [2007-10-16 10:00]

Like a charcoal drawing, it is sooo elegant! I like it a lot. It is has a timeless quality what with the details, perfect compo and amazing b/w tones. Congrats, Partha!
Fusun

•  
• dilane (8743)
• [2007-10-16 10:03]

Hi Partha,
I like this view so much, Partha. Splendid shot, really beautiful - en français je vais dire : excellent !
congratulations -
amitiés
daniel

•  
• tinamunk3 (6256)
• [2007-10-16 10:25]

Wow, this on is amazing, Partha. Great view of the family on the cart - the whip and the moving cows. And how lucky to have such clouds. Beautiful conversion to b/w.

:) Tina

•  
• kelo (481)
• [2007-10-16 10:29]

Incredible POV, for me, you have obtained a perfect compo, the scene, the sky, incredibly. I like much, congratulations.

•  
• Priam1966 (810)
• [2007-10-16 11:22]

Hello
It's a very good coposition and the Black and White is a good choice with this sky.
chris

•  
• xavis (2778)
• [2007-10-16 11:33]

Hola,
great picture. I like a lot your composition with this beauty cloudy sky, may be a little too much contrast, because there are a little of noise in black area, but in any case great picture.
Do you know how is Benoit Lange ? I think you will like his work, he is a great photograph, and your pictures reminds me his work.

Best regards,

javier

•  
• isabela_sor (32116)
• [2007-10-16 11:36]

This image is too perfect !!!A masterpiece
Congratulations
No more comments :)
Hugs

•  
• bapun1 (521)
• [2007-10-16 11:39]

With due respect, I beg to differ. I think it is not 'cow' driven, rather a ' bullock ' cart. ;)

But then, such things are not to be commented when there is a master piece of a photograph essayed in b&w is on display.

Any amount of praise will fall short. And as usual, there is a lot to learn.

Bishnu.

•  
• goodwill (2994)
• [2007-10-16 11:41]

This is a gem of the photography and one of the best landscapes captured by any artist on TE after Lonelywolf.
The wheel is in the motion and life seems slow, but the well adjusted brightness in the shot oversahdowes the contrast.
One of the best shotss from your galery partha.
Well Done Buddy,
Rajeev

•  
• jonathan_hart (13914)
• [2007-10-16 12:10]

hello Partha
good rural scene shot, B&W is interesting with that dramatic sky
regards
jo

•  
• everlasting (9457)
• [2007-10-16 12:47]

a beautiful nostaglic image emhanced by the dramactic sky, partha. Strong B&W

•  
• PierreMorel (1148)
• [2007-10-16 13:27]

Hi Partha,
That's a great shot, bright, contrasted, and very well composed. Sky is fantastic too.
Regards,
Pierre

•  
• quillo (4948)
• [2007-10-16 15:08]

-

Magnificent work in B/W, I had liked seeing it in a bigger format to enjoy moreover of the good details of the composition.
Congratulations friend Partha and thanks for sharing this small jewel.

Best regards.

-

•  
• Cormac (24523)
• [2007-10-16 17:48]

Classic shot! The black & white looks very good here, with lots of subtle tones and details. The scene is very classic too, with the cart and the group of people being nicely arranged. I like the detail in the clouds too, which is very impressive and adds a lot to the scene. Well done!

•  
• pushpinder (187)
• [2007-10-16 22:54]

brilliantly done...great monochrome shot.
compo is top class.

•  
• MarcoCertelli (325)
• [2007-10-17 0:49]

Hi Partha, a picture full of real life. Amazing sky & B&W. Very well done. Ciao, Marco.

•  
• hispic (3580)
• [2007-10-17 2:22]

Hi, Partha,
Beautiful warm tone with traditional composition.
You are not missing the moment that cow's tail raises up with the whip of a coachman.
Superb work!
Regards,
Hisashi

•  
• Dpbours (7060)
• [2007-10-17 3:20]

Hi Partha,

Oh, it is always nice to see you switch to black and white!! How rewarding! :-) Have to say, I got the shot with the wonderful blue gradual sky and this one in my favourites overview today. The blue sky is nice, but not really eventful. This one is just a little beauty! Tell me more about the black and white conversion!!

Greetings, Dennis

•  
• stiginthedump (1823)
• [2007-10-17 6:14]

I'll give you a couple of greens for this Partha, i think it might make my favorites as well! Its a cracking sky and the high contrast works well here.

•  
• mesutilgim (22189)
• [2007-10-17 7:59]

Hello dear Partha,
A timeless capture; most probably if been published somewhere it could easily be a "classic" of the art of photography in India.
Very nice pov, very good composed. Perfect sharpness and a shot with agreat story in it.
TFS
and best regards
MESUT ILGIM

•  
• sabyasachi1212 (19367)
• [2007-10-17 8:01]

Hi Partha,
I am glad I checked in today:) As others have said before me, this is exhibition material. Excellent choice for B&W.
Best Wishes
Sabyasachi

•  
• vincz (17510)
• [2007-10-18 0:53]

Fantastic image with a lot of depth. I love the fantastic feeling with this incredible sky and the traditional cow cart there. Very well done.

•  
• kiwi_explorer (12065)
• [2007-10-18 2:32]

Hi Partha,
This is an excellent composition. The tones and contrast here is just superb. Good placement of the cart and good overall dynamics. Well composed ... excellent work! tfs
Cheers,
Renier

•  
• ayniLL (0)
• [2007-10-18 3:09]

like a movie scene from india
people who is under the amazing sky look surreal
i like it
TFS

•  
• John_F_Kennedy (19175)
• [2007-10-18 4:29]

Splendid composition with wonderful perspective and great graphic effect. Well done
Best wishes,
Achim

•  
• BlkDaffyDuck (383)
• [2007-10-18 4:45]

Hello Partha,

Fabulous shot ! Subject and composition is very pleasant and good.
The sky, light and black and white are perfect too.
Thank's for this sharing and congratulation !

Regards,
Damien.

•  
• pcp (2565)
• [2007-10-18 7:01]

Wow, Impressive shot, Amazing contrast and clouds :D

Wonderful POV and Efforts.

TFS

Senthil

•  
• chrisnet (18590)
• [2007-10-18 9:09]

Hello Partha,
Excellent shot! Very impresive scene with the carriage and this amazing sky, really a great shot.
Regards

•  
• mbasil (1910)
• [2007-10-18 12:59]

Beauty, Partha. It's a wonderful composition. Nicely set with the cart moving from left to right with room in the frame to show their path and where they are headed. I think it works well in B&W. But I bet it would be a wonderful composition in color, too.

•  
• lousat (4198)
• [2007-10-18 15:54]

your gallery is empty of fantastic pics,very hard to choose the best!!! thanks for share,Luciano

•  
• paololg (4417)
• [2007-10-22 13:23]

ciao Partha,
marvellous B&W with a magic sky. The sharpnes is perfect of this nice image. Excellent work!
Paolo.

•  
• Uzi (839)
• [2007-10-23 1:17]

I'm not surprised that this photo has so many points.
starting from compostion and going by , lighting, contrast, B&W and ending on great every day scene ... this is just wondreful !
cheers
Iza

•  
• sayan (2603)
• [2007-10-23 8:03]

Hi Partha,

Its wonderful. The typical rural scene of Bengal. Looks awesome in b/w too. Particularly I like the cloud patterns!

Shubho Bijoya!

regards

sayan

•  
• Pascale (7286)
• [2007-10-23 8:18]

Bonjour Partha
Magnifique cette composition avec une excellente perspective et un ciel sublime .Ce traitement donne encore plus de force à cette photo.
J'aime beaucoup.
Félicitations pour ce travail
Amitiés

•  
• sagar (1783)
• [2007-10-25 2:10]

Hi Parthada,
Looks like still from 'Pather Panchali'. Lovely B&W tones. Wonderfully crafted. Excellent use of the clouds.
A great share,
Regards,
Sagarneel.

•  
• arijitsaha (78)
• [2007-10-26 12:33]

Hi Partha,
Just a awesome picture. And the selection of b/w mode has made this snap a painting. wonderful.

Thanks,
Arijit.

•  
• japiey (9295)
• [2007-10-29 3:57]

Hello Partha.

For many days i wasnt here...and now i realise, i missed many gems...
AN EXTRAVAGANZA....IN FRAME,....
Salutes, dear Partha.

jean paul

•  
• bruce_wayne (6352)
• [2007-10-30 5:36]

Hello Partha
very very good shot! I like this B&W...good contrasto and POV...
well done!

Alessandro

•  
• edytungkal (3297)
• [2007-10-30 22:30]

Wow... what a beautiful picture, Partha. It Looks like a perfect painting, this traditional transportation with the family and of course the dramatic sky are perfect combination. Well done, thanks :-)

daniel

•  
• dip (8127)
• [2007-10-31 4:37]

Hi Partha,
Great shot!very impressive view,
excellent use made of the lighting and shadows and perfect framed,
very well done!
Dimitris.

•  
• sn00zie (2380)
• [2007-11-12 2:42]

nice... really nice. like the composition. good idea abt the b/w

•  
• alentejo (2047)
• [2007-11-19 3:38]

This picture is wonderful Partha. Black and white was the right choice for this scene. I like the empty space on the right side. Clouds are beautiful.
Well done.

Best regards.

•  
• ayansadhu (1439)
• [2008-01-15 9:30]

WOW!!!
Back to ol-days...
Nice choice of B&W
Great composition & POV