There's no forest, but it's still ok

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• MiguelP (13103)
• [2006-01-10 17:50]
• [+]

Very good title for a very good photo Antoni. You´ve chosen the right composition to achieve the message, I think I could undersand it even with no note at all (although I like it too).

•  
• arindam_thokder (3890)
• [2006-01-10 19:30]
• [+]

Hello Antoni,

Sorry I discovered your gallery lately in TE, Such an excellent collection, I love "Monk is also a human", "Don't look back now!" "To the future", "A little mechanic" and most of the picture you took in India.
This is very complex composition, and I like the happy face of the boy in a relatively struggling life. Excellent reality of the Mumbai Slum area, I think you will love this-http://www.macalester.edu/courses/geog61/espencer/slums.html

Arindam

•  
• bnallama (3731)
• [2006-01-11 2:43]

Hi Antoni, Happy new year. A photo successfuly conveying the hard reality of these people... As always I appreciate in India they still able to come up smile on their faces....

I really like and enjoy your last postings.. TFS
Bala

•  
• eco (82)
• [2006-01-11 4:21]

witaj

niesamowite miejsca odwiedzasz, niezwyk³y urok tkwi w tej prostocie, i ten ch³ó± po prawej w ge¶cie zadowolenia, ¶wietna praca, bardzo realna, pozdrawim, rafal

•  
• jasmis (38989)
• [2006-01-11 6:35]

Super zdjęcie. Widać, że Zapuszczasz się w różne zakamarki a nie chodzisz tylko po 50 metrów w lewo i prawo od hotelu.

•  
• gebala (0)
• [2006-01-11 7:31]

witaj, ciesze sie,ze moge obejrzec Twoje zdjecia, ktorych jeszcze nie mialam okazji podziwiac:) super pokazane, podoba mi sie ta "nasza" podroz z Toba po Indiach:) pokazujesz ja zupelnie inaczej niz pozostali na tym forum, masz wiecej serca i emocji :) tak trzymac
pozd

•  
• rbcy1974 (20360)
• [2006-01-11 7:39]

Hello ANtoni
Excellent photo and note,
The photo is very sharp and the kids help give a human face to this drama, wel captured reality, good jounralism photo,
Regards
Daniel

•  
• Furachan (0)
• [2006-01-12 3:31]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Hello Antoni,
I have the highest respect for what you are doing here - love, absolutely LOVE your title. So I'm with you here and approve very much. My main suggestion would be "go with B/W". Think "Sohrab" and what he would do with this scene. It's just an idea and I could be wrong of course...
I've included a very rough (no PS available at work) WS to see how it might look in BW.
All the best,
Francis

•      
• kajspice (4519)
• [2007-08-07 9:15]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]