Canning, a place in West Bengal bordering the Sunderbans - where there exists a large populace of Royal Bengal Tigers.
This photograph is taken on the banks of river Matla that passes by this fishing village. The river is both a source of livelihood and a threat to the lives of the fisher folks, for it eats into their land on a regular basis, in the process, sometimes even their homes. Growing up here isn't easy when you constantly have to search for newer shelter every time the river erodes your home.
Critiques | Translate
Furachan (0) 2007-06-12 3:41
Great shot, Siddhartha, without a doubt - excellent use of every millimiter of the vertical frame, the little face in the bottom left pocket is a winner, virtually anchors the picture. Love the way you build a triangular shape that culminated in the boy in top of the boat. Tones may be a tad dark... at least on my screen at work.
Top notch work,
smarrero (530) 2007-06-12 3:44
interesant composition with great b&w post-processing. Well done!
Angshu (56748) 2007-06-12 4:09
Love the way you composed this & love the kid in the front with the curious stare. The kids lined up against the upturned boat leads us to the man mending it, with the BG of Matla & the broody clouds above. I used to go to Canning for three months when I was posted there & memories came rushing in after I saw your excellent picture. Darun!!
thea0211 (1365) 2007-06-12 4:29
very effective placement of the kids/people, starting with the one in the right hand corner and ending with the one sitting on the boat - nice perspective - love the overall mood - good work!
Luko (14000) 2007-06-12 4:47
Excellent framing.. of course there's the kid scratching his chin in the bottom right hand side.
I don't know what's your scanning process before you uploaded but it is quite sloppy to say the least, looks like a contact print blown to larger screen size, greyish range has suffered from a lack of contrast and I can't see any true black.
... despite of the technical shortcomings, it is still a very attractive photo.
kajspice (4542) 2007-06-12 6:13
I can't comment about the technicalities of this, but I can tell you that I like it very very much. Its packed full of excellent people/things... The composition is perhaps not perfect but it is really nice.
I think you also over-burned the sky...
Nevertheless, I think this demonstrated your potential to be an excellent photographer...
coco (30439) 2007-06-12 17:39
The noise and the black and white are useful for this photo. Also you caught a very nice moment.
SebastianSeng (354) 2007-06-14 8:40
excellent compo and moment captured, though i have to agree that the skies seems a tad over-burned.
Nevertheless, this is still a great piece of work.
sabyasachi1212 (19779) 2007-06-16 2:55
You maybe relatively new on this site but I have really come to admire your work, its not the kind of pictures I take but that doesn't stop me from appreciating this work of art. Love the use of grains, the work of TriX I guess. Excellent work.
Dpbours (222) 2007-06-16 8:39
Saw your mirror shot today and it made me wonder what happened between the monks and this mirror.
I have choosen this one. Great shot! Wonderful old touch to it - well, film and black and white ís old, but it even feels older. Don't know how to explain it. I mean, it's made in 2005 and it could as well have been 1961.
A bit too much sky, but great cropping at the bottom - explaining why you have gone for a centered horizon. Nice one!!
s10001in (0) 2007-06-18 1:50
Stong Photo with effective placement.
Rest of the things are bit at inferior side but you can improve those.
partha (14020) 2007-06-18 15:49
Its a good sensible shot.Nice candid take and the angle of view gives a nice effect.
AnimeshRay (9089) 2007-06-20 18:24
As others have already commented, this is an excellent composition, especially with the little face on the right front. The grain, the quality of the print and its scan provide a rough and simple flavor that I find quite alluring, reminiscent of an age gone by...
- Copyright: Siddhartha Hajra (sidstakes) (772)
- Genre: Places
- Medium: Black & White
- Date Taken: 2005-00-00
- Categories: Daily Life
- Camera: Nikon FG-20, Kodak Tri-X
- Photo Version: Original Version, Workshop
- Theme(s): Photographs from Rural India [view contributor(s)]
- Date Submitted: 2007-06-12 3:36
- Favorites: 1 [view]