My suggestion for the day

[AdrianW]

Would it be possible to see which critiques have been marked down - I'm not interested in <i>who</i> marked them as not useful, just which critiques were marked as such...

Preparing to eat some humble pie when someone says it already is ;-)

[adam]

"Would it be possible to see which critiques have been marked down"

I'm going to file this to look at sometime in the future. The next things I plan on doing are:

1. Revamping favorites making it easier to see which photos were added by which members. This is currently not possible.

2. 'Locking' the critiques, so that it will not be possible to edit a critique once it's been written (after a 5 minute buffer time). This will be the first part of the new system where it will be possible to reply to specific critiques and also leave comments without having to create a new discussion.

[Porteplume]

"'Locking' the critiques, so that it will not be possible to edit a critique once it's been written"

Bonjour Adam,

I will regret that, because I often looks a 2nd (or more) time to photos, and sometimes I see something "new" about that shot and I like to add comments. Or somebody else saw something and I realize I was wrong... Then it's nice to have a "second thought". Mostly I don't delete my 1st critique, just add a new date above a 2nd comment.
I also have "updated" a smile because a photo gave me that "Tilt!!!!" only the second time... ;-)
How about the "smiles"? Will they be "locked" too?

Amitiés - Viviane

[adam]

Hmm, good points. How about this:

Only one critique per photo may be made. If you realize something different about it, you may write a new critique (with a different or same smiley) which will turn the initial critique into a comment (without the smiley). This will allow members to reply to critiques/comments directly, similiar to the threaded discussions which take place now.

[Porteplume]

I think it could be a solution...

Merci - Viviane