Critiques

tcht (7298) 2009-11-24 6:17

Witaj Mikolaj
Lovely beach scene here with a nice compo. This is interesting to me because I didn't know Poland have such beaches. Good photo to share :)
Cheers
Cheuk

tcht (7298) 2009-11-24 6:15

Hi Jansci, I think this daguerreotype colouring works much better, especially with the snow, and the depth is not bad. Framing-wise I'd like it wider so that the section of road at the back - with that car - fits inside.
Just a minor point I don't like is the top right corner with the colours fading. Maybe it's demonstrating the oldness of the print but I don't think that's necessary.
Regards
Cheuk

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 10:33

Hi Helmut, amazing depth here. And you caught that warm light very well, beautiful pic~

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 10:32

hello Hartmut, beautiful scenery here! I think the lighting makes this special. Great clarity and sharpness

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 8:27

hi benny, a good composition exercise ;)　lovely textures and detail and i think the yellow works real well to complement the rather bland colours on the right. nicely done~

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 8:25

hi graham, i quite like your wide framing here. the depth is excellent too. now, to make this perfect maybe you'd need some foreground subject and dramatic lighting (lighting slightly flat here). other than that a good shot, keep it up~
cheers,
cheuk

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 8:03

Hi Afroditi, very goood atmosphere here in this shot. maybe even better if the framing is slightly wide, so we can see clearly the base of the tree. a good picture.
Cheers,
Cheuk

tcht (7298) 2009-11-23 7:08

Hello Kev,
I like the juxtaposition of the workers and the framing is great too. Maybe some extra light/shadow contrasts would spice it up a bit; overall a fine documentary shot.
Cheers,
Cheuk

tcht (7298) 2009-11-21 19:45

Another beautiful gem, Takero. Apart from the colours and details I really like the body proportion here, split evenly across the frame and to me there's no distortion at all. And the dark background works perfect too.
Cheers,
Cheuk

  tcht (7298) 2009-11-21 19:36

hi janos
whts wrong the colours here??